Recruitment

Choosing the Right Third Sector Executive Search Firm

Choosing the Right Third Sector Executive Search Firm

When selecting a third-sector executive search firm, the criterion should be suitability rather than reputation; for instance, what level of post you are filling, the size of your charity, whether you intend to make another appointment in the next two years, and whether the people you seek are currently looking. And in a presentation, firms that seem identical display very different behaviors across four questions. The article describes the various types of firms in the market and the purpose of each. If you have already decided what sort of firm you require and are selecting an agency, then the post detailing questions to be asked before you appoint an agency is likely to be more useful.

Five kinds of firm, and what each is for

Board practice in a large multi-sector firm Chief executive and chair appointments at large charities, and roles needing commercial or public sector crossover Retained, invoiced in stages Cost, and a charity brief handled alongside much larger commercial mandates
Third sector search boutique Chief executive and director roles where deep sector networks matter most Retained, invoiced in stages Narrower reach outside the sector, and rarely useful below director level
Consultancy with a dedicated charity division Director and senior manager roles, and charities that hire across several functions Contingency or retained, often no upfront fee Depth varies, so check the charity division is staffed rather than badged
Interim and fractional provider Cover during a search, or a defined piece of work with an end date Day rate with a margin Higher weekly cost, and a habit of becoming permanent by accident
Advertising led, sifted in house Well known roles with a competitive salary and an active candidate pool Advertising cost plus staff time Reaches only people who are already looking

Normally, the salary setting process starts at the top of the list and works its way through to where an affordable cost is found. Better to start at the appointment stage. Something like the appointment of a chief executive at a large charity with an iconic name and complex funding arrangements is unlikely to be serviceable through a board practice or sector-specific specialists, whereas a director of fundraising at a charity that makes a few million pounds in income would not be, as paying the ‘iconic’ board practice fees gives more kudos than it is worth.

The third one is the one we never consider. If the consultancy has a proper charity division, it does charity director and senior manager recruitment at a level where most charities tend to recruit and tends to be able to do the roles immediately above and below. The question is: Is the charity division made up of those who work on the charity roles all week or just a section on the website with a common consultant? You should find out who is in the division and what they were working on last month.

Match the firm to the appointment, not to the brand

Four questions is a more definitive method of resolving it than any credentials deck. What is the present involvement of the individual you are seeking? If the one you are seeking is doing a similar sort of work and is not going to change, you will require a firm which does mapping and calls up. When you live in a well-known, good-pay position, an advertisement will attract many candidates, and search additions will add to the cost without increasing the reach.

To be honest, what level is this? If the appointment is of a chief executive or chair, then a retained search is worth considering. For a head of service or a senior manager, it isn’t, and a company which believes every appointment is a retained search is actually selling you its process rather than solving your problem.

Will you be doing it again in two years? Most charities will. Where, for example, a series of appointments includes a fundraising director, then a finance manager and then an executive assistant, a company that only works at board level has to begin the relationship over again and pay for the briefing each time.

How much of this can you do in-house? Advertising might have the lowest fee but demands the highest number of staff hours. If no one in the charity can sift through 200 applications, then the savings in question are illusory.

The continuing relationship question

The strongest rationale for choosing a firm with a charity division over one that just undertakes board searches is continuity, but it is worth being precise about this. A search is at its most time-consuming stage when you first brief, because the consultant has to get to know an organisation afresh. Having a firm that already has your governance structure, funding profile and understanding of how your board reaches decisions on funding, strategy and policy is likely to be able to start a new search several weeks before you would get round to it with a totally fresh firm.

It does not work like this in every situation. If you appoint a director once every five years you will never develop a relationship so there is every reason to use a specialist boutique for this sort of one-off search.

Commercial checks most boards skip

All employment agencies doing business in the UK are subject to the Employment Agencies Act 1973 and the Conduct of Employment Agencies and Employment Businesses Regulations 2003. These provide that the terms of business should be agreed in writing before any work is undertaken and set out how fees and information about candidates should be managed. You should request these terms prior to the pitch rather than afterwards; if an agency refuses to give them until after you have viewed or met the candidates or takes a period of time over preparing the terms, this should serve as an indication to you.

In addition, check on these four matters, and settle on just one email: whether a candidate is a member of a professional body such as APSCo or the Recruitment and Employment Confederation and whether their specific code of conduct is applicable. Valid certifications, professional indemnity and employers’ liability insurance. Identify the individual taking care of your account and also the effect on the job search if he leaves mid-process. Written copies of the conditions on discounts or reimbursements are different; a no-fee alternative, a discount on a sliding scale, as well as a complete repayment are three various options and also explained with similar terms.

Candidate data, which almost nobody asks about

A search firm will hold a considerable amount of sensitive information relating to people who have never entered an application for a role in a process that is inherently incompatible with data protection legislation. The Information Commissioner has issued guidance on employment practices in relation to recruitment and selection that is relevant for all parties involved, including headhunters and recruitment consultancies as well as employers, and covers the entire process from job advertisement, and what to do with the candidate’s personal data once the process has been completed, identifying that much recruitment related information is likely to be sensitive on health, diversity, or criminal conviction grounds.

As the charity is rated in terms of the treatment of its people, the reputation of the charity is equally as significant as its conformity. The three points that should be asked, and the answers provided, can be:

  • Requesting the privacy declaration they provide to candidates (not the one on the site) – if they cannot produce it instantly, then they are unlikely to be issuing it.
  • Asking for the length of time they keep candidates’ data they approached but declined, and the reason for doing so.
  • Asking the panel if the discrimination monitoring information is distinguished from the rest of the info the panel views-it should be, and certainly, a company who stores the data and then passes it directly to the panel has not believed it through.

What separates two firms that look identical

Between three companies each having the right set of qualifications and each charging comparable fees, their qualifications become irrelevant; what the boards wanted is no longer applicable. It is the consultant who gets the higher levels in charities because he is able to offer a convincing dialogue with an existing director on your behalf; meet the person who will be doing the work and politely refuse if someone else is doing the presentation, then hand back the work.

If you are asking, do they say yes? Then a consultancy that takes on everything and says yes-even those that pay less than the average salary and other roles in the job description-is unlikely to then do complicated deals down the road If the search is on hold, then just ask what is done in week seven when the long list is short. A good answer is the mapping and the brief; a bad answer is an advertisement.

Where The Maine Group sits

Maine Group is a recruitment consultancy, and its charity division, Maine Charity, has been dealing with not-for-profit organizations for over 25 years. Services for employers in London have been offered by the company since 1987, and it has five divisions that work with charity, human resources, business support, sales and marketing, and consultancy, so one relationship can include an appointment of a director along with the other roles associated with it.

The company applies the same approach-what it calls The Maine Method-in all situations and doesn’t reserve it for posts at board level only; it goes to the client’s own workplace before a search begins; it charges no upfront fees and offers a financial guarantee on appointments of 100 days at 100 percent. It is a package that lends itself well to charities that need to recruit for a range of departments, whereas a charity might be better served by a specialised board practice making a single appointment at the top end of the sector, and we would accept that.

Frequently asked questions

What’s the difference between an executive search company and a recruitment agency?

Search companies recruit passively by nominating potential candidates (a market map), they will also invoice clients in stages regardless of whether you engage their services. Recruitment agencies promote job vacancies and utilise their current candidate database and tend to charge only on successful placement of a candidate (some use the search methodology but charge as an agency).

What is the price of executive search for the third sector?

Retained fees are usually quoted as a percentage between 20% and 30% of first year salary in instalments, with charity rates normally being less than commercial prices. The contingency amounts are lower and are paid on the successful placement. For interim positions, the fee is charged on a per diem basis with a margin.

Is it viable for a tiny charity to employ an executive search organisation?

In most cases, not for anything below a director level. Provided the salary is comparable to the job market, and you have a high profile, advertising can reach an active candidate group at a fraction of the cost. The search fee is paid when the candidate is working somewhere else and not currently looking for a job.

Can one organisation undertake both the director appointment role and the support person job?

Yes, but only if it has substantial capability in these areas rather than just a charity page on its website and a generalist. The advantage is that the agency will be well acquainted with your organisation, saving several weeks on subsequent searches.

Meeta Sahni

About the Author

Meeta Sahni

Meeta brings 25 years of experience in talent consulting, with a focus on leadership, wellness, and empowering people. She speaks and coaches on mental health in the workplace, women in business, and authentic leadership.