Recruitment

How to find top charity executive recruitment agencies

How to find top charity executive recruitment agencies

What does an executive search firm do? They find, approach, and assess candidates for such senior posts in charities as chief executive, director of fundraising, finance director, director of services, and interim managers to be employed for an agreed period. Because the executive search firm you choose will determine what board members will ever see and meet, this is an area where much more thought than usual needs to go into a decision.

Charity boards generally appoint a chief executive once every five or six years, a rate far too slow to give an effective feel for making this type of appointment. The next section summarizes the process of an executive search for the charity sector, what a sector specialist will do that a generalist agency won’t, and the questions that separate the two.

What a charity executive search is, and how it differs from ordinary recruitment

Executive search is, by definition, an active approach. A consultant will explore the market for a role, map out who is doing it now or who is up a level and approach those people directly. Contingency recruitment is a reactive approach: advertise, trawl your own current database, and send you the CVs of anyone who applies. You pay a contingency agency when someone is appointed; you pay a search firm on a staged basis whether or not someone is appointed.

With a charity’s chief executive, a search is normally the most appropriate route since the best candidates are not actively searching for new roles and will therefore not be visiting job boards. A fundraising manager or an executive assistant, on the other hand, can usually be found through a contingency arrangement more cheaply.

Few firms use a search methodology for jobs that would otherwise be advertised on contingency terms. The Maine Group is one of those firms. Its consultants initially meet all clients in the workplace before starting a search, and the firm applies that same technique, dubbed The Maine Method, to each of its five divisions, which includes Maine Charity. The upshot: a mid-range charity job is researched and contacted, not advertised and screened.

Why sector specialism changes who reaches your shortlist

Pay is the obvious example. The latest result from ACEVO’s Pay and Equalities Survey 2025 included responses from 703 of the UK’s charity chief executives. The median was £59,850. Charity Finance’s 2025 survey of the 100 largest charities in the UK showed the median was £192,000-a climb from £175,000 in 2023 and £155,000 in 2019. In both these cases, it is the same job but in a different section of the sector. A recruitment agency which cannot identify where in those two extremes your organisation sits would provide poor advice to candidates, who would then be likely to walk away from your offer.

The same survey also revealed that for charity chief executives, there is a 10.6 per cent pay gap between men and women: men with median salaries of £64,067 versus £57,250 for women. A search firm which captures and compares its own data (for longlist, shortlist and appointment) on diversity will be able to demonstrate to your panel at the outset where candidates are stopping. A firm which does not will deliver the shortlist in black-and-white – as though it fell from the sky.

A firm with sector knowledge will be able to make smaller distinctions. A consultant who has appointed fundraising directors can distinguish one who has helped generate unrestricted income from scratch from one who has managed a major statutory grant. A generalist sees both as £4m of raised funds.

The compliance work that sits behind a charity appointment

From 1 August 2018, the rules about automatic disqualification have been extended to senior charity managers as well as trustees. The most senior manager who reports directly to the board is the chief executive, and the most senior person in the charity who has control of money is the finance director. These are defined by the role they do rather than by their job title. The grounds for disqualification are convictions for dishonesty or deception that are not spent, certain offenses related to terrorism, bribery, and money laundering, contempt of court, and having a notice imposing listing on the sex offenders register.

In practice, though, the charity must ask for the declaration before the appointment, not after; the Charity Commission has model declarations for trustees and senior managers and a disqualified person may make an application to the Commission for a dispensation. Ask another agency which does that step in its procedures. An experienced search agency in the sector will say that it obtains the declaration during the offer stage and checks the Individual Insolvency Register, the Companies House register of disqualified directors and the Commission’s register of removed trustees. A less competent agency will just say that you are legally obliged to do that, which is correct, and do nothing further.

Two additional points should be added to this discussion. If a posting involves working with children or vulnerable adults, the work should be DBS checked at the relevant level, with the organisation aware of this requirement in advance and not simply subjecting a basic check to the posting. In addition, any agency registered to do business in the UK should be following the guidance of the Employment Agencies Act 1973 and the Conduct of Employment Agencies and Employment Businesses Regulations 2003 on fees, candidate data and terms of business. Participation in the Recruitment and Employment Confederation would be a reasonable marker of an agency that understands the need to follow the law, but by itself that is not enough.

Seven questions to ask before you sign

Work your way through each of the agencies you have found using this process and then review the information you have gained:

  • How many posts have you supported as a chief executive or director in the last two years?
  • Can you give me two references for my work?
  • Who runs this search daily, and will she or he come to the briefing, shortlist, and final panel?
  • How do you produce the longlist?
  • If a company says it has built a list for mapping out different agencies, it means that it is doing an active search. In the opposite case, if a company says it has a huge database, it means it is doing a database recall.
  • How do you approach disqualification, references, and the right to work?
  • What information do you gather about diversity?
  • Will it be given to our panel?
  • What are your fees?
  • What if the successful candidate leaves within six months?
  • Who writes the material for applicants?
  • Can I see it?
  • Would I be able to see material that your company has written for a similar vacancy?

Fees, guarantees and what happens when it goes wrong

Retention search billing can be divided into three parts: when the firm is retained, upon delivery of the shortlist and upon the commencement of employment by the candidate. Fees are often set as a percentage of the first year’s salary for the placed candidate (ranging from 20% to 30%), and charity rates are usually lower than commercial rates. Contingency agencies will only be billed when a candidate is placed, at a lower rate. Rate

Get the failure words in text before you appoint anyone, because agencies use the word “guarantee” for three quite totally different things. A gratis substitute in case of failure signifies the agency will look for once more completely free, which means very little when you’ve lost confidence in the firm. A rebate gives a proportion of the cost on a sliding scale, so a month-to-month career change might give you 30% of it back. A refund is simply that: you get your cash back.

The Maine Group offers 100 days at 100% cash protection with no fees in advance, and our fee is payable only after a successful placement. This is more than the usual industry standards and, as such, offers a fair basis on which to compare other agencies’ terms.

Keep the board close to the process.

Board effectiveness and equality, diversity and inclusion are principles in the Charity Governance Code, and a chief executive appointment is a good opportunity to put them into practice. You need to be clear in your mind beforehand about who will be on the panel, who will take the final decision, and what will happen if they disagree – and to discuss it at the briefing meeting. Search consultants regularly point out how interestingly good candidates disappear when it takes two or three weeks to put together an unplanned panel.

Use the briefing meeting to determine the timetable, and put the panel dates into your diary at the same time. It is very reasonable to expect a search for a charity’s chief executive to take from six to 12 weeks from the briefing date to making an offer, taking into account the appointee’s notice period, which is usually three months at that level. If a firm are promising to produce a shortlist significantly faster, they are often doing so because they already have someone in mind.

Signs to walk away

CVs received within 48 hours of the initial contact with no consultant involved in the process having met your team or visited the environment where the work will take place; A consultant failing to disclose the name of the individual carrying out the work; No charity client prepared to accept a reference call; terms of business are not being produced until your panel has met with the candidates; you are being referred from a firm that can only offer you an interim worker on a day rate.

A practical first step

Draft a one-page profile on salary range, reporting relationships, panel members, timing, and the performance expectations for the appointee in the first year. Send this to two or three agencies and, in writing, ask for each agency’s process for the search, their fees, and their failure as well as success criteria. The quality of the written response you receive will say far more than any credentials.

Maine Charity-Working with not-for-profit organisations for over 25 years. To read more about the positions we have successfully recruited for the not-for-profit sector in the United Kingdom, consult our job boards on fundraising and philanthropy, executive assistants, HR, and senior leadership. Call us on 020 7734 7341 or go to the Maine Charity division page.

Frequently asked questions

What does a charity executive search involve?

Charity executive search is a proactive form of recruitment for senior jobs in the charity sector. Instead of advertising a role and waiting to receive applicants, the consultant carries out a market mapping exercise, makes direct approaches, and evaluates candidates against a brief agreed with your board.

How much do charity executive recruitment agencies charge?

Search fees (retained) are usually 20%-30% of the successful candidate’s first year salary and paid in instalments. Rates in the charity sector are usually lower than commercial rates. Contingency agencies only charge if they recruit someone. The Maine Group will not charge up front, and we only take our fee when the candidate has started work.

What is the length of the search for a charity’s chief executive officer?

The usual period between the briefing and offer is six to 12 weeks, plus the leave period of the successful candidate (which at the chief executive level is normally three months).

Do charity recruitment agencies provide trustees’ recruitment as well as that of staff?

Yes, they do. As trustee roles are typically paid differently and involve a different process and different pool of candidates, it is important to specifically ask the firm whether it has done a trustee search, rather than take it for granted it is something it does as part of its executive search activity.

Must the agency be based in London?

On the other hand, the majority of searches are by phone and video, and there is more need for knowledge of the sector than for a location. Being based in London gives an advantage if the role necessitates a number of face-to-face meetings or if candidates in a particular specialist area tend to be based in the capital.

Meeta Sahni

About the Author

Meeta Sahni

Meeta brings 25 years of experience in talent consulting, with a focus on leadership, wellness, and empowering people. She speaks and coaches on mental health in the workplace, women in business, and authentic leadership.