How does charity CEO recruitment work?
There are four ways in which the process of recruiting an executive for a charity differs from that of a commercial approach. The trustee board is the employer and makes the appointment. The salary is made public. Certain types of candidates, including existing trustees, will need authorization from the Charity Commission before they can be appointed, and the appointment is subject to statutory requirements for certain appointing bodies, unlike commercial appointments.
Any other differences can be inferred from these four. This article covers who is making the decision and what stages a board may take, how the salary is set, and who can be legally appointed. A stage-by-stage process is covered in our article on the nonprofit executive search process.
The board is the employer, not the outgoing chief executive
The trustees appoint and, if necessary, dismiss the chief executive, which is a collective decision of the whole board that cannot be delegated to the departing individual. While the departing chief executive obviously has the most knowledge about the job in the room and should be consulted about the brief, they have no voice in selecting their replacement. Boards that fail to distinguish between these two roles usually find out at a later date in a failed appointment when no one can claim credit for the choice.
The board delegates the appointment to a committee of usually three or four trustees, generally chaired by the chair, which then makes a report to the full board. The minutes should reflect the delegation along with the decision rule in the case of an unresolved deadlock. In the Charity Governance Code, board effectiveness is dealt with as a principle in its own right, and the chief executive appointment is the situation in which the principle is tested.
There is no doubt that having staff involved is valuable, but there needs to be a limit. When the senior managers facilitate a panel, they can give information which would otherwise not be possible, but it needs to be clear beforehand that they are in an advisory capacity. Otherwise, the charity will accidentally be creating a second decision-making body, and a good candidate will be turned away by a body with no power to decide.
The four routes to an appointment
| Internal promotion | A credible successor is already in post and the strategy is continuing | A closed process is hard to defend if the appointment later goes wrong |
| Open advertising | The role is well known in the sector and the salary is competitive | Reaches only candidates who are actively looking |
| Retained executive search | The strongest candidates are employed elsewhere, or the brief is unusual | Fees are payable in stages whether or not you appoint |
| Interim then permanent | The board needs stability first and clarity on the role second | An acting-up arrangement can quietly become the appointment |
Cost is used as a guideline for choosing which avenue to go down, but cost should not be the first thing to ask. The right question should be the current job of the person you want to appoint. If the person you want to appoint is currently running a similar charity, it is unlikely that an ad will attract the attention of the right candidate, but a search will.
If the sector is already familiar with your organisation and the salary on offer is competitive, advertising can produce a good response at only a fraction of the cost of a retained search.
The interim route deserves to be treated more seriously than it is currently. Appointing an interim chief executive while the board figures out its remit is a perfectly fair and appropriate course of action. But it is not acceptable to allow a senior manager to undertake the role for nine months without arriving at a decision, since by month nine the appointment will have been made in all but name and no outsider will stand a chance. A date should be set for the acting period to end on the day it begins.
How the salary is set, and why it becomes public
Charity pay is presented quite differently to commercial pay. Charities SORP specifies that when preparing accruals accounts, a charity is to include the number of employees receiving remuneration within each band from £60,000 upwards in £10,000 bands, with a nil value if there are none in that band, and also the total cost of benefits by key management personnel. In addition, trustees are to disclose to the auditors in the annual report how they assessed the pay of key management personnel, including the indicators used. The higher pay figures from the annual returns are obtained from the Charity Commission.
Therefore, in relation to recruitment, the salary needs to be a decision of governance pre the recruitment process and one that can be justified to the electorate 12 months later. Note the salary band and reasoning behind it based on the market data. The most frequent cause of the failure of a charity CEO recruitment to succeed during the offer stage is trying to use a salary band derived from the previous year’s payroll and ignoring the current market.
The ACEVO Pay and Equalities Survey 2025, although just a simple snapshot of data from 703 charity chief executives, of this sample the median was £59,850. Charity Finance’s Study of the UK’s 100 Largest Charities 2025-CEO salary: £192,000 (compared to £175,000 in the 2023 study). Your own salary is somewhere between these two figures, depending on income, staff numbers, geography, and complexity of your funding model, not how much you believe it should be.
Who can and cannot be appointed
Three rules have been chosen, with only two removed, and boards can only see these two at a very late stage. The first is automatic disqualification, bringing senior charity managers under the regulations (introduced on 1 August 2018) so that the chief executive (or equivalent) who reports directly to the board and the highest-ranking person with control over money (regardless of designation) are caught. This declaration is signed prior to appointment, and we publish sample declarations and can exempt a person from disqualification on application.
The second is often more tempting to take on boards because it is the ‘problem’ that needs to be solved. For a founder-led or small charity, the most common person to be ‘taken on’ internally is a trustee or someone who has just stepped down as trustee. In the vast majority of cases, if you want to appoint someone to the charity as an employee (a paid staff member), first you will need to get approval from the Charity Commission, unless the charity’s governing document already means you can pay a trustee.
You should check the document carefully, as many words that seem to allow a trustee to be paid for their work do not necessarily apply when considering employment as a staff member.
First, the fact that the resignation has occurred cannot be a justification; it is the rule regardless of whether the trustee resigned before or after becoming a trustee, and a trustee who has received payment from the charity might be asked to return it. A trustee who has received payments without authority might be asked to do so, although the only strict exception to this will be when the charity can demonstrate that the individual did not obtain the post due to their position as a trustee and that there are no other conflicts of interest; a charity will find it easier to meet this condition if the individual resigned prior to the job being defined and was not involved in designing it.
What it costs and who pays
Retained search fees are paid in stages-normally when the appointment is made, when the shortlist is received, and when the start date is reached. These are payable even if you do not subsequently appoint. Payment for contingency recruitment is only made on the successful appointment of the candidate. Advertising produces the lowest fee structure but is most expensive in staff time, as a member of the charity will need to spend time sifting through applications and liaising with candidates.
The Maine Group does not take a fee before the start of the process but takes its fee when the appointment is made and offers a finance guarantee on the sum for 100 days at 100 percent. No matter what the board finally opts for, finance has to be considered before the search begins, and the signer of the engagement agreement has to be decided in advance because otherwise, the recruitment fee that is finally paid into the accounts without a preceding minutes entry is a sure subject for an audit discussion nobody wants.
After the appointment, the board is still the employer
The appointment does not end the responsibilities of the board and, in fact, implements them. It is preferable to agree on the criteria to be used for the first year of the appointee’s appointment before the commencement date, while the two parties still have clear recollections of what was said during the interview, and the date of the first appraisal should be fixed at that time. As charity chief executives tend to give a three-month notice, there is normally sufficient time to carry out this process satisfactorily.
Know who the chief executive’s line manager is-most commonly the chair-and what happens if that relationship breaks down. Two of the UK’s 100 biggest charities had no chief executive at the time of the Charity Finance’s Chief Executive Survey 2025, with 30% of their leaders having been in post for a year or less (though that in itself is a common part of chief executive life, some of it is because boards got the ‘right’ person in and then failed to develop and lead them).
Getting help with the appointment
The Maine Group for over 25 years has delivered recruitment services to not-for-profit organizations through the division known as Maine Charity, specializing in the recruitment of fundraising and philanthropy staff, PA/executive support, HR, and senior executive appointments. It has been recruiting for companies in London since 1987 and applies what it describes as the Maine Method to every role, not just those at board level.
If there is to be an appointment of a chief executive, the first thing to do is to take up the salary range, the panel, the timetable, and whether any internal or trustee candidates are being discussed-because that will influence the process. I can be contacted on 020 7734 7341.
Frequently asked questions
Who appoints the chief executive of a charity?
Typically, the board of trustees delegates this duty to a three- or four-member committee, who present the trustee’s slating recommendation to the entire board. The retiring chief executive has the opportunity to weigh in, but the decision ultimately does not rest with him.
Can a trustee of a charity also be its chief executive?
Not always, but sometimes. If you will be engaging a trustee, in most cases, you will need Charity Commission approval beforehand unless the governing document makes provision for the appointment, and this is not affected by any subsequent resignation of the trustee. This should be addressed before you set about recruiting the trustee.
Does a charity have to advertise its chief executive’s job?
It’s not a legal requirement to advertise, as open recruitment gives the trustees a way to prove they have acted in the best interests of the charity (crucial if you have an internal candidate or a trustee in the role or if the appointment is later challenged).
How is the charity’s CEO’s pay terms decided?
The pay band is set by the board before recruitment starts and will take into account sector comparatives and the charity’s income, size, and complexity. Under the Charities SORP, those with higher pay will have to be disclosed in the financial accounts, and trustees should be able to explain how they decide on remuneration for key management personnel; the reasoning should therefore be recorded when the decision is made.