The nonprofit organisation’s executive search process includes ten steps, beginning with the board agreeing to the mandate and concluding with the first 100 days of the new appointment; the period from the initial briefing until offer-making takes six to twelve weeks prior to a notice period being served. Because the greatest risk lies in the first three phases, the board devotes the least amount of time to them.
Top jobs in the sector are routinely empty-so this really matters. In our 2025 Chief Executive Survey, The Charity Finance Survey, 7 of the top hundred UK charities had no chief executive working for them when the survey was conducted, and 30% of the executives we could find data for had held the role for a year or less. We explain what happens at each stage, who is doing it and why it is often not successful in the next section.
The nonprofit executive search process at a glance
| 1. Mandate | Board agrees the role, the budget and the panel | Week 0 to 1 |
| 2. Appoint the search partner | Terms, fee stages and failure terms signed | Week 1 to 2 |
| 3. Briefing | Consultant visits, role and success measures defined | Week 2 |
| 4. Market mapping | Research team builds the target list | Week 2 to 4 |
| 5. Approach and screening | Direct approaches, first interviews by the consultant | Week 3 to 6 |
| 6. Longlist review | Panel sees the mapping and the shortlist rationale | Week 6 |
| 7. Assessment | Competency interviews, task, psychometrics if used | Week 6 to 8 |
| 8. Final panel | Formal interviews, stakeholder sessions, decision | Week 8 to 10 |
| 9. Pre-appointment checks | References, disqualification declaration, DBS, right to work | Week 10 to 11 |
| 10. Offer and onboarding | Offer, notice period, first 100 days plan | Week 11, plus notice |
Stage by stage
- The board agrees on the mandate.
Without first recruiting, the board will decide what kind of person it is looking for. This includes deciding the salary, reporting arrangements, the two or three objectives the appointee is expected to deliver in the first year, and whether the organisation needs a like-for-like replacement or a different type of leader. The job description of an outgoing chief executive lists what the last person did in the role-not a good starting point for the next appointment.
Name the appointment panel, including who will make the final decision, and what the chairperson should do if the panel is divided. Also at this meeting, diarize the panel’s dates. Searches often fail to find any good candidates when three or four weeks pass between searches because the panel that was always there had not been scheduled in the first place.
- The selection of a search partner
Retained search services are spread over the course of the project, by stages, usually when the candidate is appointed, when the shortlist is supplied, and at the start date. In contingency work, we are paid once a candidate is placed. It is essential that at this stage there is a clear fee structure in writing and an explanation of the failure criteria-agencies will talk about guaranteed working in three different ways: free replacement search, rebate on a sliding scale, or a full refund. The Maine Group does not charge in advance, charges its fees on placement and guarantees the appointment for 100 days at 100% of the fee.
- The briefing meeting
The visit of the consultant; it is this visit which earns a fee for the reputable search company, as it is the brief which results from it that is handed to the candidates. The Maine Group always insist on seeing all its clients in their own office in advance of any search in all of its divisions, including Maine Charity, and this applies equally to appointments to charity chief executive positions.
From the briefing, two documents are generated. The person specification makes a distinct difference between genuinely critical features and those which are recycled from a previous advertisement. The candidate pack is the document which would persuade an incumbent chief executive to take a call about your organization; if it looks like a standard advert with a logo on the front cover, expect a brief and slender longlist.
- Research and market mapping
That becomes a list of organizations and named individuals in the sector targeted, in the income band, or with the specialisms specified in the brief. In the case of a chief executive post in a charity, it might be a list of sixty or more, derived from charities of a similar scale, from related subsectors, and from those in the commercial or public sector who have relevant experience. Ask to see the map rather than a summary of it. In a similar vein, when a firm says it will be contacting organisations, it is doing a search; when a firm says it has contacts, it is merely reciting its own data bank.
- The approach and the initial screening
The consultant communicates directly with candidates, typically by phone, and performs a preliminary interview with each candidate who answers the job advertisement. The aim of the interview is to assess the candidates for their qualifications. One of the most well-known candidates is the commercial director who wants to enter the industry, and the simple question is whether he understands the concept of the governance structure, where the board is the employer, and the amount of the income is limited.
Through this information, the consultant will gain an idea of salary without spending resources and time on the process. The ACEVO Pay and Equalities Survey 2025 is based on the responses received from 703 chief executives of different charities and shows that the median salary of a chief executive officer is equal to £59,850, while Charity Finance mentions that salaries in the top 100 charities were £192,000.
- Review of the longlist by the panel
Because the panel has the benefit of seeing the longlist alongside the mapping that created it, the trustees will be aware of not only the ones remaining in the race but of those previously approached and decided not to run. In a typical chief executive search for a charity, the longlist will normally comprise between twelve and fifteen people. This is also the last opportunity to change the brief before having to restart the process.
- Assessment
The assessment process usually includes a competency interview using the person specification, a task or presentation set around a real issue for your organisation, and for larger charities, a psychometric or leadership assessment. For each candidate, you should apply the same set of criteria and indicate how well they meet these criteria. The key here is that the criteria are written down and applied in the same way for all candidates, and this is important to good decision-making (see nine).
You might hold meetings with the senior management team and, where appropriate, service users of the charity. This will expose problems a panel interview alone will not. Any meetings should be advisory, and this should be made clear in advance-otherwise you will have created a second decision-making group.
- Final panel interviews
Typically, there are three or four candidates for the final panel. The panel interview is on the same day and asks the same questions in the same order, as far as possible, and will not make a decision until candidates have left. If the panel cannot decide, the chair will pick one decision rule established in stage 1, so stage 1 is crucial.
- Pre-appointment checks
Charity appointment checks include those not mandated for commercial appointments. Since 1 August 2018, the automatic disqualification rules have been widened to include senior managers of charities as well as trustees and now extend to the most senior manager who reports directly to the trustees and the most senior person with effective control of the charity. It is this role which is relevant rather than the job title. Disqualifying reasons include unspent convictions for dishonesty or deception, certain terrorist related offences, money laundering and bribery offences, court orders for contempt, and being on the sex offenders register.
The declaration must be received before the appointment takes place, not afterwards. The Charity Commission has sample declarations and an individual may apply for a waiver if they are disqualified. You should also check the Individual Insolvency Register, the Companies House register of disqualified directors and the Charity Commission register of removed trustees. If the appointment involves regulated activity with children or adults at risk, you need to establish the required level of DBS check rather than automatically selecting the basic level.
- The offer, the notice period and onboarding
Because chief executives usually resign with three months’ notice, the search that runs past 11 weeks will likely have a starting date in the following quarter – so try to make use of that. Agree with the appointee what the first 100 days of their new role will look like, including which trustees they will meet during the first week and what the board will want to see at their first meeting of the board. Also agree what performance measures will be used for the first year, while between them they still remember what they were told during the interview.
Where diverse shortlists are won and lost
The pay differential, based on the average income (referred to as the ‘mean’) of charities’ chief executives, was 10.6 percent in the 2025 ACEVO pay survey, with men earning on average £64,067 compared with £57,250 for women. The sector-wide picture emerges from decisions made when individuals are appointed to CEO roles, which a board has the power to influence through its recruitment process. These are the third and fourth stages of the recruitment process.
However, most of the ‘good work’ is done on stages four and five. The Equality Act 2010, section 158, provides the legal framework for proactive measures, such as targeted activity, wider mapping, and review of language in the candidate pack, to encourage applications for jobs from under-represented groups, including the appointment stage, which will lead to a diverse longlist.
There have been many controversies over the application of Section 159 that came into force on 6 April 2011, mainly due to its limited applicability and several misconceptions. An employer may have recourse to Section 159 only in one circumstance: that the candidate has made an application and his/ her qualifications are comparable to other applicants in that selection process; the employer believes strongly that this group is underachieving, and he/she cannot apply the section of the recruitment process generally. The decision in Furlong v Chief Constable of Cheshire Police shows that the police force was guilty of breaking the law as it resorted to a tie-breaker without having the certainty that the candidates were exactly the same.
What derails a nonprofit executive search
- The agreement was reached by email, not in person, and it is only at the shortlist stage that the panel realizes that they had wanted different things.
- The dates for the panel are set after the search has begun, which results in a delay of several weeks between the longlist and the offer and thus imposes a cost on the candidates.
- The salary band was determined on the basis of last year’s payroll figures rather than current sector benchmarks, this being discovered at the time the offer was made.
- The assessment scores were recorded in individual notebooks, with no reasons given for the decisions or any basis for a tie-break.
- The declarations of disqualification have been sent after the offer has been issued.
- As there is no onboarding plan, a leader who has been recruited to make some change takes three months merely deciding whom to ask.
Where a specialist agency changes the outcome
For more than 25 years, the Maine Group has been providing not-for-profit organisations with services through its Maine Charity arm. The services include making fundraising and philanthropy appointments and providing executive assistants and people in senior leadership roles. As the firm has been recruiting for companies based in London since 1987, it incorporates what it calls The Maine Method in every job it fills, rather than just at board-level appointments.
The best first step when a chief executive or director appointment is imminent within the next two quarters is to prepare a one-page summary outlining the salary range, reporting structure, appointment panel and objectives for the first year. You should call 020 7734 7341 to discuss it prior to the vacancy.
Frequently asked questions
How long does an executive search by a charity typically take?
From briefing to offer plus notice (normally 3 months), the process generally takes 6–12 weeks, plus a week or two at the start to allow time for the board to agree on the mandate and select and brief a search firm.
What is the difference between executive search and recruitment?
Executive search is a proactive approach: the consultant maps the market and searches for targets who are not advertising and may not be actively looking.
Who should be on the appointment panel?
The chair, 2 trustees (or 3 if the structure permits), and the senior member of staff representing the organisation – make sure the panel is not so large that it can’t be convened at short notice. If you want wider stakeholder input into a decision, arrange a hearing as a separate event rather than a larger panel.
What are the basic legal checks that must be made before appointing a charity chief executive?
Declaration signed by the appointee and completed prior to appointment-confirms no automatic disqualification; right-to-work checks and references if the post involves regulated activity; fit person requirements and criminal record declaration for posts involving regulated activity with children/adults at risk.