How long does charity director recruitment take?
It takes between six and twelve weeks between the initial enquiry and offer acceptance and four to six months between the initial enquiry and a new director in place because most charity directors give three months’ notice. Planning begins with the latter figure, and then a quarter of a year is lost as it is the first figure in practice. It is this ‘final figure’ where most of the damage occurs when the chief executive, who has given the board the final figure of when his new fundraising director will be in place (having commenced his search in March), informs them of when the offer would be made (June) without giving them information of when the new director will be in post.
Two numbers, not one
The timeline for me is called the recruitment period by the recruiter because it includes the preliminaries, mapping, approaches, assessment, panel and decision. The “desk time” includes the notice period, which is three months in the non-charitable situation in a most general not-for-profit sector. Include the period from verbal offer to contract acceptance in the non-charitable condition, which might not be very dramatic; for example, it may take two weeks to nail down the job description and start date for a family holiday. When talking to the board, include both figures at the same time, make the second one more prominent, then you don’t need to don’t need that discussion of progress in nine weeks.
How long each director role takes
| Director of fundraising | 8 to 12 weeks | 3 months | 5 to 6 months |
| Finance director | 8 to 14 weeks | 3 months | 5 to 7 months |
| Director of services or operations | 8 to 12 weeks | 3 months | 5 to 6 months |
| HR director | 6 to 10 weeks | 3 months | 4 to 6 months |
| Director of communications | 6 to 10 weeks | 1 to 3 months | 3 to 5 months |
| Interim director | 1 to 3 weeks | None to 2 weeks | Under a month |
The finance director is the slowest of all the group, for two reasons. One is the pool of potential candidates, since a charity finance director must meet all the technical requirements and speak the language of restricted funds, SORP and audit cycle; the assessing process is more likely to include a technical stage than with other directors. Second, even though more and more boards are starting to avoid finance appointments at the year-end, the balance of preferred appointment dates still tends to be at the pre-audit point, removing weeks of availability.
The most competitive: the fundraising director. Interviewers in this area often approach talented candidates in the early stages, will be juggling several simultaneously, and inevitably give up when a process stalls. In no other field do candidates in the fundraising director search give up so quickly if there’s been no contact for a week.
The head of communications and marketing is the one that takes the longest of all the permanent positions; the pool of candidates is larger, since, in fact, those from agencies or the commercial world are appropriate, and the notice period is usually one or two months instead of three.
What lengthens the timeline
There are six main reasons for delay, only one of which is caused by the recruiter. The single worst thing you could do is set a salary band below market rate and find you only realise it at the offer stage once ten weeks’ work has gone down the drain. Benchmarking should be carried out well in advance of the search rather than when a candidate turns down an offer. The ACEVO Pay and Equalities Survey 2025, which is based on data from 703 charity chief executives, is a good guide as to how high you should go for people above your own directors, and a specialist recruiter will be able to tell you what comparable director posts paid in the last twelve months.
Timing is also a factor; if panels can fit in when convenient rather than the pre-booked weeks between the longlist and the first interview go up by two or three, and similarly between the final and the eventual appointment. When director appointments are placed on the board agenda for sign-off, it is the board schedule that sets the minimum-this is a quarterly cycle, so it can take 6 weeks.
Senior charity recruitment slows down for the month of August and for the two weeks before and after Christmas. All the interview panels go on holiday, the candidates disappear, and the referees are untraceable. A typical search that begins in mid-July is very similar to one that kicks off in September.
The fourth pre-employment check is a pre-employment check that people often underestimate. Where the position involves regulated activity with children or vulnerable adults, the post is subject to an enhanced DBS check. Each month, the Disclosure and Barring Service produces reports on police activity and results for enhanced checks have been averaging around 14 days, with a range of 10-20 working days being a typical expectation. The application can be referred to a police force with a backlog, which can take much longer. Checks should be started on the day the offer is accepted, not when the contract is returned.
The fifth on the list is references. You need to give your line manager’s reference, but only after you’ve given your current boss due notice that you are seeking new employment-which means you should keep your references till after the offer comes through. You need to work out in advance what you will accept temporarily and don’t try to fix your starting date on a reference that you haven’t yet asked for.
Counter-offers arrive sixth, and they’re more common at the director level than Boards expect. Your recently recruited fundraising director has just left you, and there’s a short-term income issue at a charity that offers a fortnight to resolve it. It’s explained that the candidate has been involved with your mission right through rather than being persuaded by the offer at the end.
What genuinely shortens it
The panel dates are booked before the search begins, with a replacement for each panel member being appointed. The decision rule that has been agreed upon at the briefing stages means that a split panel will not have an extra two weeks. Instead of having three rounds, there is one assessment day, which the candidates prefer and prevents a fortnight.
There is temporary cover, which removes the pressure that normally results in the panel electing the least suitable candidate of the group.
The recruiter is familiar with the organisation, since the initial briefing is the slowest part of a new working relationship. The fact that a shortlist is achieved more quickly does not mean that it has saved money; if the appointment is not successful, then the weeks saved will have been wasted because a ten-day shortlist is merely a database search.
Working backwards from the date you need someone
Rather, take the plan from the date the person is asked to appear at their desk rather than the date you want to begin the recruitment process. For a fundraising director who must start on 1 April (the beginning of the financial year), the process is reversed and the length of time from demand to appointment is calculated as three months to go to an offer in January, ten weeks for the recruitment process to reach a deadline of 31 October and two weeks in which to date the recruiter and book the panel days to reach 1 October.
When fast is a warning sign
That a director was appointed just three weeks after the standard timeframe suggests one of three things:
- the position was always going to go to a nominee of the appointing organization,
- the recruiter had a particular individual in mind and did not conduct any market research, or
- the salary offered was so far above the market rate that the first candidate who was contacted agreed straight away.
Beware the first two if the board gives the go-ahead. If a recruiter says they can offer a shortlist within a week, find out which organisations they will be contacting and see if the answer is got some names.
Interim cover while you recruit
From a theoretical perspective, it should be between two weeks for the interim, but it may happen after a couple of days following the decision. Sometimes, you will have to cover operations but not strategy; in those cases, for instance, you should have to complete an audit or to put some suggestions before a deadline, and similar cases. The latter must not be forgotten, however: as soon as you have signed a temporary contract, you should also put the end date for this temporary appointment; no exception in those cases. If the temporary contract had been valid for nine months, this would be inevitable and for good: as a result, the final search would not have appealing candidates applying later.
Talking to us about a director appointment
Since 1982, we have been a specialist recruiting firm for the not-for-profit sector, offering expertise in all aspects of fundraising and philanthropy, finance, human resources, executive assistance, and the hiring of senior leaders-permanent, temporary, or interim-for not-for-profit organisations; we have also been recruiting for companies in London since 1987. The first step if you want a director in place by a specific date is to begin with that date and, from that date, establish together whether the date is reasonable. Call us on 020 7734 7341.
Frequently asked questions
How much to employ a charity fundraising director?
8-12 weeks from a brief to acceptance of the offer, 5-6 months to the first day, with a three-month notice period. Fundraising candidates will be managing multiple conversations at the same time, and if you lose candidates with gaps in excess of a week between stages, you may lose good candidates.
Why do charity director positions take so long to fill?
The majority of the recruitment process will normally take between six and twelve weeks. The only other factors that can influence the time frame are Notice periods, the availability of the panel to fit in with the board’s timetable, holidays, and the pre-employment checks (these include the enhanced DBS if the role is regulated activity).
Can you find a charity director in a month?
In many cases an interim appointment can be made in a matter of weeks; if a permanent appointment can be made in under one month, then this means only one person could have held this position, and this should be clarified prior to the board approving the appointment.
What’s the notice period for a charity director?
Three months is standard at the director level, and in communications and marketing roles, one or two months more is normal. Find out about it in the first interview rather than the offer interview, because it will shift your start date by a quarter.