Recruitment

Nonprofit Executive Search Process Explained (Step-by-Step)

The nonprofit organisation’s executive search process includes ten steps, beginning with the board agreeing to the mandate and concluding with the first 100 days of the new appointment; the period from the initial briefing until offer-making takes six to twelve weeks prior to a notice period being served. Because the greatest risk lies in the first three phases, the board devotes the least amount of time to them.

Top jobs in the sector are routinely empty-so this really matters. In our 2025 Chief Executive Survey, The Charity Finance Survey, 7 of the top hundred UK charities had no chief executive working for them when the survey was conducted, and 30% of the executives we could find data for had held the role for a year or less. We explain what happens at each stage, who is doing it and why it is often not successful in the next section.

The nonprofit executive search process at a glance

1. Mandate Board agrees the role, the budget and the panel Week 0 to 1
2. Appoint the search partner Terms, fee stages and failure terms signed Week 1 to 2
3. Briefing Consultant visits, role and success measures defined Week 2
4. Market mapping Research team builds the target list Week 2 to 4
5. Approach and screening Direct approaches, first interviews by the consultant Week 3 to 6
6. Longlist review Panel sees the mapping and the shortlist rationale Week 6
7. Assessment Competency interviews, task, psychometrics if used Week 6 to 8
8. Final panel Formal interviews, stakeholder sessions, decision Week 8 to 10
9. Pre-appointment checks References, disqualification declaration, DBS, right to work Week 10 to 11
10. Offer and onboarding Offer, notice period, first 100 days plan Week 11, plus notice

Stage by stage

  1. The board agrees on the mandate.

Without first recruiting, the board will decide what kind of person it is looking for. This includes deciding the salary, reporting arrangements, the two or three objectives the appointee is expected to deliver in the first year, and whether the organisation needs a like-for-like replacement or a different type of leader. The job description of an outgoing chief executive lists what the last person did in the role-not a good starting point for the next appointment.

Name the appointment panel, including who will make the final decision, and what the chairperson should do if the panel is divided. Also at this meeting, diarize the panel’s dates. Searches often fail to find any good candidates when three or four weeks pass between searches because the panel that was always there had not been scheduled in the first place.

  1. The selection of a search partner

Retained search services are spread over the course of the project, by stages, usually when the candidate is appointed, when the shortlist is supplied, and at the start date. In contingency work, we are paid once a candidate is placed. It is essential that at this stage there is a clear fee structure in writing and an explanation of the failure criteria-agencies will talk about guaranteed working in three different ways: free replacement search, rebate on a sliding scale, or a full refund. The Maine Group does not charge in advance, charges its fees on placement and guarantees the appointment for 100 days at 100% of the fee.

  1. The briefing meeting

The visit of the consultant; it is this visit which earns a fee for the reputable search company, as it is the brief which results from it that is handed to the candidates. The Maine Group always insist on seeing all its clients in their own office in advance of any search in all of its divisions, including Maine Charity, and this applies equally to appointments to charity chief executive positions.

From the briefing, two documents are generated. The person specification makes a distinct difference between genuinely critical features and those which are recycled from a previous advertisement. The candidate pack is the document which would persuade an incumbent chief executive to take a call about your organization; if it looks like a standard advert with a logo on the front cover, expect a brief and slender longlist.

  1. Research and market mapping

That becomes a list of organizations and named individuals in the sector targeted, in the income band, or with the specialisms specified in the brief. In the case of a chief executive post in a charity, it might be a list of sixty or more, derived from charities of a similar scale, from related subsectors, and from those in the commercial or public sector who have relevant experience. Ask to see the map rather than a summary of it. In a similar vein, when a firm says it will be contacting organisations, it is doing a search; when a firm says it has contacts, it is merely reciting its own data bank.

  1. The approach and the initial screening

The consultant communicates directly with candidates, typically by phone, and performs a preliminary interview with each candidate who answers the job advertisement. The aim of the interview is to assess the candidates for their qualifications. One of the most well-known candidates is the commercial director who wants to enter the industry, and the simple question is whether he understands the concept of the governance structure, where the board is the employer, and the amount of the income is limited.

Through this information, the consultant will gain an idea of salary without spending resources and time on the process. The ACEVO Pay and Equalities Survey 2025 is based on the responses received from 703 chief executives of different charities and shows that the median salary of a chief executive officer is equal to £59,850, while Charity Finance mentions that salaries in the top 100 charities were £192,000.

  1. Review of the longlist by the panel

Because the panel has the benefit of seeing the longlist alongside the mapping that created it, the trustees will be aware of not only the ones remaining in the race but of those previously approached and decided not to run. In a typical chief executive search for a charity, the longlist will normally comprise between twelve and fifteen people. This is also the last opportunity to change the brief before having to restart the process.

  1. Assessment

The assessment process usually includes a competency interview using the person specification, a task or presentation set around a real issue for your organisation, and for larger charities, a psychometric or leadership assessment. For each candidate, you should apply the same set of criteria and indicate how well they meet these criteria. The key here is that the criteria are written down and applied in the same way for all candidates, and this is important to good decision-making (see nine).

You might hold meetings with the senior management team and, where appropriate, service users of the charity. This will expose problems a panel interview alone will not. Any meetings should be advisory, and this should be made clear in advance-otherwise you will have created a second decision-making group.

  1. Final panel interviews

Typically, there are three or four candidates for the final panel. The panel interview is on the same day and asks the same questions in the same order, as far as possible, and will not make a decision until candidates have left. If the panel cannot decide, the chair will pick one decision rule established in stage 1, so stage 1 is crucial.

  1. Pre-appointment checks

Charity appointment checks include those not mandated for commercial appointments. Since 1 August 2018, the automatic disqualification rules have been widened to include senior managers of charities as well as trustees and now extend to the most senior manager who reports directly to the trustees and the most senior person with effective control of the charity. It is this role which is relevant rather than the job title. Disqualifying reasons include unspent convictions for dishonesty or deception, certain terrorist related offences, money laundering and bribery offences, court orders for contempt, and being on the sex offenders register.

The declaration must be received before the appointment takes place, not afterwards. The Charity Commission has sample declarations and an individual may apply for a waiver if they are disqualified. You should also check the Individual Insolvency Register, the Companies House register of disqualified directors and the Charity Commission register of removed trustees. If the appointment involves regulated activity with children or adults at risk, you need to establish the required level of DBS check rather than automatically selecting the basic level.

  1. The offer, the notice period and onboarding

Because chief executives usually resign with three months’ notice, the search that runs past 11 weeks will likely have a starting date in the following quarter – so try to make use of that. Agree with the appointee what the first 100 days of their new role will look like, including which trustees they will meet during the first week and what the board will want to see at their first meeting of the board. Also agree what performance measures will be used for the first year, while between them they still remember what they were told during the interview.

Where diverse shortlists are won and lost

The pay differential, based on the average income (referred to as the ‘mean’) of charities’ chief executives, was 10.6 percent in the 2025 ACEVO pay survey, with men earning on average £64,067 compared with £57,250 for women. The sector-wide picture emerges from decisions made when individuals are appointed to CEO roles, which a board has the power to influence through its recruitment process. These are the third and fourth stages of the recruitment process.

However, most of the ‘good work’ is done on stages four and five. The Equality Act 2010, section 158, provides the legal framework for proactive measures, such as targeted activity, wider mapping, and review of language in the candidate pack, to encourage applications for jobs from under-represented groups, including the appointment stage, which will lead to a diverse longlist.

There have been many controversies over the application of Section 159 that came into force on 6 April 2011, mainly due to its limited applicability and several misconceptions. An employer may have recourse to Section 159 only in one circumstance: that the candidate has made an application and his/ her qualifications are comparable to other applicants in that selection process; the employer believes strongly that this group is underachieving, and he/she cannot apply the section of the recruitment process generally. The decision in Furlong v Chief Constable of Cheshire Police shows that the police force was guilty of breaking the law as it resorted to a tie-breaker without having the certainty that the candidates were exactly the same.

What derails a nonprofit executive search

  • The agreement was reached by email, not in person, and it is only at the shortlist stage that the panel realizes that they had wanted different things.
  • The dates for the panel are set after the search has begun, which results in a delay of several weeks between the longlist and the offer and thus imposes a cost on the candidates.
  • The salary band was determined on the basis of last year’s payroll figures rather than current sector benchmarks, this being discovered at the time the offer was made.
  • The assessment scores were recorded in individual notebooks, with no reasons given for the decisions or any basis for a tie-break.
  • The declarations of disqualification have been sent after the offer has been issued.
  • As there is no onboarding plan, a leader who has been recruited to make some change takes three months merely deciding whom to ask.

Where a specialist agency changes the outcome

For more than 25 years, the Maine Group has been providing not-for-profit organisations with services through its Maine Charity arm. The services include making fundraising and philanthropy appointments and providing executive assistants and people in senior leadership roles. As the firm has been recruiting for companies based in London since 1987, it incorporates what it calls The Maine Method in every job it fills, rather than just at board-level appointments.

The best first step when a chief executive or director appointment is imminent within the next two quarters is to prepare a one-page summary outlining the salary range, reporting structure, appointment panel and objectives for the first year. You should call 020 7734 7341 to discuss it prior to the vacancy.

Frequently asked questions

How long does an executive search by a charity typically take?

From briefing to offer plus notice (normally 3 months), the process generally takes 6–12 weeks, plus a week or two at the start to allow time for the board to agree on the mandate and select and brief a search firm.

What is the difference between executive search and recruitment?

Executive search is a proactive approach: the consultant maps the market and searches for targets who are not advertising and may not be actively looking.

Who should be on the appointment panel?

The chair, 2 trustees (or 3 if the structure permits), and the senior member of staff representing the organisation – make sure the panel is not so large that it can’t be convened at short notice. If you want wider stakeholder input into a decision, arrange a hearing as a separate event rather than a larger panel.

What are the basic legal checks that must be made before appointing a charity chief executive?

Declaration signed by the appointee and completed prior to appointment-confirms no automatic disqualification; right-to-work checks and references if the post involves regulated activity; fit person requirements and criminal record declaration for posts involving regulated activity with children/adults at risk.

The Maine Group Admin

About the Author

The Maine Group Admin

Meeta brings 25 years of experience in talent consulting, with a focus on leadership, wellness, and empowering people. She speaks and coaches on mental health in the workplace, women in business, and authentic leadership.

Recruitment

How long does charity director recruitment take?

How long does charity director recruitment take?

It takes between six and twelve weeks between the initial enquiry and offer acceptance and four to six months between the initial enquiry and a new director in place because most charity directors give three months’ notice. Planning begins with the latter figure, and then a quarter of a year is lost as it is the first figure in practice. It is this ‘final figure’ where most of the damage occurs when the chief executive, who has given the board the final figure of when his new fundraising director will be in place (having commenced his search in March), informs them of when the offer would be made (June) without giving them information of when the new director will be in post.

Two numbers, not one

The timeline for me is called the recruitment period by the recruiter because it includes the preliminaries, mapping, approaches, assessment, panel and decision. The “desk time” includes the notice period, which is three months in the non-charitable situation in a most general not-for-profit sector. Include the period from verbal offer to contract acceptance in the non-charitable condition, which might not be very dramatic; for example, it may take two weeks to nail down the job description and start date for a family holiday. When talking to the board, include both figures at the same time, make the second one more prominent, then you don’t need to don’t need that discussion of progress in nine weeks.

How long each director role takes

Director of fundraising 8 to 12 weeks 3 months 5 to 6 months
Finance director 8 to 14 weeks 3 months 5 to 7 months
Director of services or operations 8 to 12 weeks 3 months 5 to 6 months
HR director 6 to 10 weeks 3 months 4 to 6 months
Director of communications 6 to 10 weeks 1 to 3 months 3 to 5 months
Interim director 1 to 3 weeks None to 2 weeks Under a month

The finance director is the slowest of all the group, for two reasons. One is the pool of potential candidates, since a charity finance director must meet all the technical requirements and speak the language of restricted funds, SORP and audit cycle; the assessing process is more likely to include a technical stage than with other directors. Second, even though more and more boards are starting to avoid finance appointments at the year-end, the balance of preferred appointment dates still tends to be at the pre-audit point, removing weeks of availability.

The most competitive: the fundraising director. Interviewers in this area often approach talented candidates in the early stages, will be juggling several simultaneously, and inevitably give up when a process stalls. In no other field do candidates in the fundraising director search give up so quickly if there’s been no contact for a week.

The head of communications and marketing is the one that takes the longest of all the permanent positions; the pool of candidates is larger, since, in fact, those from agencies or the commercial world are appropriate, and the notice period is usually one or two months instead of three.

What lengthens the timeline

There are six main reasons for delay, only one of which is caused by the recruiter. The single worst thing you could do is set a salary band below market rate and find you only realise it at the offer stage once ten weeks’ work has gone down the drain. Benchmarking should be carried out well in advance of the search rather than when a candidate turns down an offer. The ACEVO Pay and Equalities Survey 2025, which is based on data from 703 charity chief executives, is a good guide as to how high you should go for people above your own directors, and a specialist recruiter will be able to tell you what comparable director posts paid in the last twelve months.

Timing is also a factor; if panels can fit in when convenient rather than the pre-booked weeks between the longlist and the first interview go up by two or three, and similarly between the final and the eventual appointment. When director appointments are placed on the board agenda for sign-off, it is the board schedule that sets the minimum-this is a quarterly cycle, so it can take 6 weeks.

Senior charity recruitment slows down for the month of August and for the two weeks before and after Christmas. All the interview panels go on holiday, the candidates disappear, and the referees are untraceable. A typical search that begins in mid-July is very similar to one that kicks off in September.

The fourth pre-employment check is a pre-employment check that people often underestimate. Where the position involves regulated activity with children or vulnerable adults, the post is subject to an enhanced DBS check. Each month, the Disclosure and Barring Service produces reports on police activity and results for enhanced checks have been averaging around 14 days, with a range of 10-20 working days being a typical expectation. The application can be referred to a police force with a backlog, which can take much longer. Checks should be started on the day the offer is accepted, not when the contract is returned.

The fifth on the list is references. You need to give your line manager’s reference, but only after you’ve given your current boss due notice that you are seeking new employment-which means you should keep your references till after the offer comes through. You need to work out in advance what you will accept temporarily and don’t try to fix your starting date on a reference that you haven’t yet asked for.

Counter-offers arrive sixth, and they’re more common at the director level than Boards expect. Your recently recruited fundraising director has just left you, and there’s a short-term income issue at a charity that offers a fortnight to resolve it. It’s explained that the candidate has been involved with your mission right through rather than being persuaded by the offer at the end.

What genuinely shortens it

The panel dates are booked before the search begins, with a replacement for each panel member being appointed. The decision rule that has been agreed upon at the briefing stages means that a split panel will not have an extra two weeks. Instead of having three rounds, there is one assessment day, which the candidates prefer and prevents a fortnight.

There is temporary cover, which removes the pressure that normally results in the panel electing the least suitable candidate of the group.

The recruiter is familiar with the organisation, since the initial briefing is the slowest part of a new working relationship. The fact that a shortlist is achieved more quickly does not mean that it has saved money; if the appointment is not successful, then the weeks saved will have been wasted because a ten-day shortlist is merely a database search.

Working backwards from the date you need someone

Rather, take the plan from the date the person is asked to appear at their desk rather than the date you want to begin the recruitment process. For a fundraising director who must start on 1 April (the beginning of the financial year), the process is reversed and the length of time from demand to appointment is calculated as three months to go to an offer in January, ten weeks for the recruitment process to reach a deadline of 31 October and two weeks in which to date the recruiter and book the panel days to reach 1 October.

When fast is a warning sign

That a director was appointed just three weeks after the standard timeframe suggests one of three things:

  • the position was always going to go to a nominee of the appointing organization,
  • the recruiter had a particular individual in mind and did not conduct any market research, or
  • the salary offered was so far above the market rate that the first candidate who was contacted agreed straight away.

Beware the first two if the board gives the go-ahead. If a recruiter says they can offer a shortlist within a week, find out which organisations they will be contacting and see if the answer is got some names.

Interim cover while you recruit

From a theoretical perspective, it should be between two weeks for the interim, but it may happen after a couple of days following the decision. Sometimes, you will have to cover operations but not strategy; in those cases, for instance, you should have to complete an audit or to put some suggestions before a deadline, and similar cases. The latter must not be forgotten, however: as soon as you have signed a temporary contract, you should also put the end date for this temporary appointment; no exception in those cases. If the temporary contract had been valid for nine months, this would be inevitable and for good: as a result, the final search would not have appealing candidates applying later.

Talking to us about a director appointment

Since 1982, we have been a specialist recruiting firm for the not-for-profit sector, offering expertise in all aspects of fundraising and philanthropy, finance, human resources, executive assistance, and the hiring of senior leaders-permanent, temporary, or interim-for not-for-profit organisations; we have also been recruiting for companies in London since 1987. The first step if you want a director in place by a specific date is to begin with that date and, from that date, establish together whether the date is reasonable. Call us on 020 7734 7341.

Frequently asked questions

How much to employ a charity fundraising director?

8-12 weeks from a brief to acceptance of the offer, 5-6 months to the first day, with a three-month notice period. Fundraising candidates will be managing multiple conversations at the same time, and if you lose candidates with gaps in excess of a week between stages, you may lose good candidates.

Why do charity director positions take so long to fill?

The majority of the recruitment process will normally take between six and twelve weeks. The only other factors that can influence the time frame are Notice periods, the availability of the panel to fit in with the board’s timetable, holidays, and the pre-employment checks (these include the enhanced DBS if the role is regulated activity).

Can you find a charity director in a month?

In many cases an interim appointment can be made in a matter of weeks; if a permanent appointment can be made in under one month, then this means only one person could have held this position, and this should be clarified prior to the board approving the appointment.

What’s the notice period for a charity director?

Three months is standard at the director level, and in communications and marketing roles, one or two months more is normal. Find out about it in the first interview rather than the offer interview, because it will shift your start date by a quarter.

The Maine Group Admin

About the Author

The Maine Group Admin

Meeta brings 25 years of experience in talent consulting, with a focus on leadership, wellness, and empowering people. She speaks and coaches on mental health in the workplace, women in business, and authentic leadership.

Recruitment

Choosing the Right Third Sector Executive Search Firm

Choosing the Right Third Sector Executive Search Firm

When selecting a third-sector executive search firm, the criterion should be suitability rather than reputation; for instance, what level of post you are filling, the size of your charity, whether you intend to make another appointment in the next two years, and whether the people you seek are currently looking. And in a presentation, firms that seem identical display very different behaviors across four questions. The article describes the various types of firms in the market and the purpose of each. If you have already decided what sort of firm you require and are selecting an agency, then the post detailing questions to be asked before you appoint an agency is likely to be more useful.

Five kinds of firm, and what each is for

Board practice in a large multi-sector firm Chief executive and chair appointments at large charities, and roles needing commercial or public sector crossover Retained, invoiced in stages Cost, and a charity brief handled alongside much larger commercial mandates
Third sector search boutique Chief executive and director roles where deep sector networks matter most Retained, invoiced in stages Narrower reach outside the sector, and rarely useful below director level
Consultancy with a dedicated charity division Director and senior manager roles, and charities that hire across several functions Contingency or retained, often no upfront fee Depth varies, so check the charity division is staffed rather than badged
Interim and fractional provider Cover during a search, or a defined piece of work with an end date Day rate with a margin Higher weekly cost, and a habit of becoming permanent by accident
Advertising led, sifted in house Well known roles with a competitive salary and an active candidate pool Advertising cost plus staff time Reaches only people who are already looking

Normally, the salary setting process starts at the top of the list and works its way through to where an affordable cost is found. Better to start at the appointment stage. Something like the appointment of a chief executive at a large charity with an iconic name and complex funding arrangements is unlikely to be serviceable through a board practice or sector-specific specialists, whereas a director of fundraising at a charity that makes a few million pounds in income would not be, as paying the ‘iconic’ board practice fees gives more kudos than it is worth.

The third one is the one we never consider. If the consultancy has a proper charity division, it does charity director and senior manager recruitment at a level where most charities tend to recruit and tends to be able to do the roles immediately above and below. The question is: Is the charity division made up of those who work on the charity roles all week or just a section on the website with a common consultant? You should find out who is in the division and what they were working on last month.

Match the firm to the appointment, not to the brand

Four questions is a more definitive method of resolving it than any credentials deck. What is the present involvement of the individual you are seeking? If the one you are seeking is doing a similar sort of work and is not going to change, you will require a firm which does mapping and calls up. When you live in a well-known, good-pay position, an advertisement will attract many candidates, and search additions will add to the cost without increasing the reach.

To be honest, what level is this? If the appointment is of a chief executive or chair, then a retained search is worth considering. For a head of service or a senior manager, it isn’t, and a company which believes every appointment is a retained search is actually selling you its process rather than solving your problem.

Will you be doing it again in two years? Most charities will. Where, for example, a series of appointments includes a fundraising director, then a finance manager and then an executive assistant, a company that only works at board level has to begin the relationship over again and pay for the briefing each time.

How much of this can you do in-house? Advertising might have the lowest fee but demands the highest number of staff hours. If no one in the charity can sift through 200 applications, then the savings in question are illusory.

The continuing relationship question

The strongest rationale for choosing a firm with a charity division over one that just undertakes board searches is continuity, but it is worth being precise about this. A search is at its most time-consuming stage when you first brief, because the consultant has to get to know an organisation afresh. Having a firm that already has your governance structure, funding profile and understanding of how your board reaches decisions on funding, strategy and policy is likely to be able to start a new search several weeks before you would get round to it with a totally fresh firm.

It does not work like this in every situation. If you appoint a director once every five years you will never develop a relationship so there is every reason to use a specialist boutique for this sort of one-off search.

Commercial checks most boards skip

All employment agencies doing business in the UK are subject to the Employment Agencies Act 1973 and the Conduct of Employment Agencies and Employment Businesses Regulations 2003. These provide that the terms of business should be agreed in writing before any work is undertaken and set out how fees and information about candidates should be managed. You should request these terms prior to the pitch rather than afterwards; if an agency refuses to give them until after you have viewed or met the candidates or takes a period of time over preparing the terms, this should serve as an indication to you.

In addition, check on these four matters, and settle on just one email: whether a candidate is a member of a professional body such as APSCo or the Recruitment and Employment Confederation and whether their specific code of conduct is applicable. Valid certifications, professional indemnity and employers’ liability insurance. Identify the individual taking care of your account and also the effect on the job search if he leaves mid-process. Written copies of the conditions on discounts or reimbursements are different; a no-fee alternative, a discount on a sliding scale, as well as a complete repayment are three various options and also explained with similar terms.

Candidate data, which almost nobody asks about

A search firm will hold a considerable amount of sensitive information relating to people who have never entered an application for a role in a process that is inherently incompatible with data protection legislation. The Information Commissioner has issued guidance on employment practices in relation to recruitment and selection that is relevant for all parties involved, including headhunters and recruitment consultancies as well as employers, and covers the entire process from job advertisement, and what to do with the candidate’s personal data once the process has been completed, identifying that much recruitment related information is likely to be sensitive on health, diversity, or criminal conviction grounds.

As the charity is rated in terms of the treatment of its people, the reputation of the charity is equally as significant as its conformity. The three points that should be asked, and the answers provided, can be:

  • Requesting the privacy declaration they provide to candidates (not the one on the site) – if they cannot produce it instantly, then they are unlikely to be issuing it.
  • Asking for the length of time they keep candidates’ data they approached but declined, and the reason for doing so.
  • Asking the panel if the discrimination monitoring information is distinguished from the rest of the info the panel views-it should be, and certainly, a company who stores the data and then passes it directly to the panel has not believed it through.

What separates two firms that look identical

Between three companies each having the right set of qualifications and each charging comparable fees, their qualifications become irrelevant; what the boards wanted is no longer applicable. It is the consultant who gets the higher levels in charities because he is able to offer a convincing dialogue with an existing director on your behalf; meet the person who will be doing the work and politely refuse if someone else is doing the presentation, then hand back the work.

If you are asking, do they say yes? Then a consultancy that takes on everything and says yes-even those that pay less than the average salary and other roles in the job description-is unlikely to then do complicated deals down the road If the search is on hold, then just ask what is done in week seven when the long list is short. A good answer is the mapping and the brief; a bad answer is an advertisement.

Where The Maine Group sits

Maine Group is a recruitment consultancy, and its charity division, Maine Charity, has been dealing with not-for-profit organizations for over 25 years. Services for employers in London have been offered by the company since 1987, and it has five divisions that work with charity, human resources, business support, sales and marketing, and consultancy, so one relationship can include an appointment of a director along with the other roles associated with it.

The company applies the same approach-what it calls The Maine Method-in all situations and doesn’t reserve it for posts at board level only; it goes to the client’s own workplace before a search begins; it charges no upfront fees and offers a financial guarantee on appointments of 100 days at 100 percent. It is a package that lends itself well to charities that need to recruit for a range of departments, whereas a charity might be better served by a specialised board practice making a single appointment at the top end of the sector, and we would accept that.

Frequently asked questions

What’s the difference between an executive search company and a recruitment agency?

Search companies recruit passively by nominating potential candidates (a market map), they will also invoice clients in stages regardless of whether you engage their services. Recruitment agencies promote job vacancies and utilise their current candidate database and tend to charge only on successful placement of a candidate (some use the search methodology but charge as an agency).

What is the price of executive search for the third sector?

Retained fees are usually quoted as a percentage between 20% and 30% of first year salary in instalments, with charity rates normally being less than commercial prices. The contingency amounts are lower and are paid on the successful placement. For interim positions, the fee is charged on a per diem basis with a margin.

Is it viable for a tiny charity to employ an executive search organisation?

In most cases, not for anything below a director level. Provided the salary is comparable to the job market, and you have a high profile, advertising can reach an active candidate group at a fraction of the cost. The search fee is paid when the candidate is working somewhere else and not currently looking for a job.

Can one organisation undertake both the director appointment role and the support person job?

Yes, but only if it has substantial capability in these areas rather than just a charity page on its website and a generalist. The advantage is that the agency will be well acquainted with your organisation, saving several weeks on subsequent searches.

Meeta Sahni

About the Author

Meeta Sahni

Meeta brings 25 years of experience in talent consulting, with a focus on leadership, wellness, and empowering people. She speaks and coaches on mental health in the workplace, women in business, and authentic leadership.

Recruitment

How Executive Search Firms Support Charity Trustee Recruitment

How Executive Search Firms Support Charity Trustee Recruitment

When helping a board to find charity trustees, search firms are able to track down and approach prospective trustee candidates who would never otherwise be discovered by a board. They do not appoint the candidates, but it is the board that chooses, in accordance with the rules in the governing document, and the search process provides them with the slate of options which are presented to them.

It is in this way that the division is more significant than in a paid appointment, and consequently trustee searches are charged for, scheduled, and executed differently to those for directors.

Why do boards reach outside their own networks?

A survey of over 2,000 trustees conducted by the Charity Commission and Pro Bono Economics in April 2025 found that only 6% of trustees had come into the role via advertisement. Just over half of charities are recruited through relationships. About 29% of trustees were recruited by the chair, and about 25% were recruited by another board member.

The boards assembled through recruitment from existing members are the same as the people already in the room. The study found the median age of trustees was 65–69, with over half retired, 8% aged under 45, and 1% aged 30 or under, and that female trustees made up 43% of the total, up from 36% in 2017, while people from ethnic minorities made up 8% of the total, compared with 17% in the population. The survey also discovered that 12% of boards had no legal experience or skills among their trustees.

After all that, the Charity Commission updated the guidance on recruiting and appointing new trustees (CC30) on 14 May 2025, with advice such as extending the advertising outlets you consider, conducting skills audits mapped to the organisation’s priorities and creating role descriptions that separate the skills and qualities a person needs before their appointment from the skills and qualities they may not have but can acquire after appointment. Using a search firm to do what CC30 asks could be one of many things you do as a trustee group to address the issues raised in the previous blog; it is one of many options and not necessarily the correct one.

Trustee recruitment against director recruitment

Paid No, expenses only unless the governing document or the Commission permits payment Yes, salaried
Who appoints The board, the members, or another body, as the governing document specifies The board, or the chief executive for roles below director
Governed by The charity’s governing document and charity law Employment law and the contract
Fee basis for a search firm Fixed fee, or pro bono, since there is no salary to take a percentage of Percentage of first-year salary
Typical timeline Three to six months, set by the board or AGM calendar Six to twelve weeks to offer
What the firm delivers A field of candidates for the board or members to choose from A shortlist and, usually, an appointment

What a search firm actually does on a trustee brief

A skills audit before anything else

What should happen to the unfilled vacancy at board level is the first thing to decide, and bear in mind that this is a different question to the one that has just opened up. Being a treasurer may well be due to chagrin at being treasurer, not to a shortage of accountants, not when the board has already two and knows nothing about IT. A properly functioning consultant will want to see the skills matrix for the board, and notice if there isn’t one.

Lived experience is the only thing that is respected, not a box to be ticked. CC30 recommends that boards want a blend of technical expertise, sector knowledge, community links and lived experience, and because none of these four elements are usually present in one person.

A role description that describes a real commitment

Descriptions of the trustee role do not usually specify how long they take, and this is how you can most quickly lose an able trustee within 12 months. Tell people how many board meetings are planned, what the commitment to committees is likely to be, and whether the meetings are going to be daytime or evening and whether a personal presence is necessary. Bear in mind that at evening meetings in central London most full-time workers are left out and that you should at least take note of the fact that you have excluded most of the available human resources by the arrangements you have made.

Mapping and approach

What a board can’t do is undertake this process. The consultant creates a shortlist of potential candidates with the necessary skill set, which includes people from diverse sectors and not necessarily those working already within the charity, and then makes contact directly. Approaching a trustee is a much tougher ask than speaking to a director, as there is no salary involved, so the case has to be sold – to the chair of the trustees and the value of the experience.

Screening and the checks that follow

The consultant considers the candidate against the terms of the job description, considers their motivation, and identifies any real or potential conflicts of interest at the earliest possible opportunity; while a potential or current employee of a large funder or chair of a charity whose work in the same locality overlaps with the role is not excluded, any conflict must be declared prior to the board meeting the individual rather than after.

Eligibility checks are applied just as to senior roles. The automatic disqualification rules apply, and the declaration has to be signed before appointment to trustee. The governing document may have its own criteria such as membership. The company’s work ends with a field of candidates and a recommendation. Even though under CC30 a board may delegate some elements of the trustee search to its employees or to others, the trustees are still charged with designing a good process, and it is the trustees who make the appointment under the governing document. When your members appoint trustees at an AGM, the search terminates at the nomination stage, and the timetable then becomes part of the AGM calendar, not that of the search agent. The standard fee for paid roles is a percentage of the first year’s salary, and it does not extend to an unpaid role. Trustee recruitment is therefore charged in one of three ways.

  • The most common arrangement in the case of chair and treasurer searches is a fixed project fee.
  • Work is carried out on a pro bono basis or at a greatly reduced price, usually from a firm that is already providing paid services to the charity.
  • The following organisations offer free routes: Reach Volunteering, Getting on Board, NCVO’s trustee resources, and the Charity Commission all provide a way of connecting boards with potential trustees at no cost.

Treat them with all the respect and care you would if you were going to employ somebody. For a general trustee position at a small to medium charity, a carefully worded advertisement via a trustee finder service should bring in a number of applications. Paid search is only cost-effective if it is truly hard-to-find-a chair, a treasurer with appropriate charity finance experience, an unsuitable board that needs to change its make-up, rather than replace a trustee who has left, or a struggling charity that is looking for trustees with an understanding of the issues it faces.

When a board should not commission a search

If there is no consensus on the gaps, a search will produce a handful of candidates to a short-list nobody has confidence in. First do the skills audit. And if all you have is a difficult board, recruitment won’t solve your problem.

Deliberate conflict, a dominant Chair, or not having a working committee structure will rapidly make the trustees you recruited walk out the door, and the recruitment fee will simply buy you a delay. If you already have a known candidate who has agreed, put them in the advert. Searching for an outcome wastes candidates’ time and doesn’t give the board what it thinks it does.

Talking to us about a board vacancy

For the past 25 years, the Maine Group has been putting not-for-profit organisations in touch with recruitment specialists through its Maine Charity division, and it has been supporting companies in London with their recruitment needs since 1987 within the disciplines of charity, human resources, business support, sales and marketing, utilizing the Maine Method for each and every assignment. When a vacancy arises within the board, the first and foremost information that’s extremely helpful to discuss is the type of skills or qualities that they’re lacking, how your governing documents provide for appointments, and whether or not these free routes are likely to provide you with the opportunity of it. We’re able to tell you whether or not they’re. Call us on 020 7734 7341.

Frequently asked questions

Can a recruitment agency be a trustee of a charity?

The trustees of other charities and people or organisations specified in the charity’s governing document. An agency of a recruitment agency assesses the prospects, and the decision is made by an individual or an organisation named in the governing document.

What is the average salary of a Trustee?

The average cost of recruiting a Trustee is variable and depends on the provider. On average, a final fixed project cost is generally paid, as there is no salary from which to take a percentage, and sometimes the firm works for nothing for investment trustees. Any free trustee finder services should be tried in the first instance for general trusts. It is a reasonable time scale, as the process of searching is rarely the bottleneck.

Are charity trustees paid?

No, charities normally do not pay their trustees, but they can claim expenses. These can include child care and travel expenses. Donations should be approved by the governing document or by the Charity Commission.

Should we use a search consultancy or do the searching ourselves?

For most general vacancies, it is best to advertise first by using a trustee finder. Use a search when the brief is specific or too narrow, for example, where the role is a chair or treasurer or where the board is to replace the whole board rather than fill a vacancy.

Meeta Sahni

About the Author

Meeta Sahni

Meeta brings 25 years of experience in talent consulting, with a focus on leadership, wellness, and empowering people. She speaks and coaches on mental health in the workplace, women in business, and authentic leadership.

Recruitment

How to find top charity executive recruitment agencies

How to find top charity executive recruitment agencies

What does an executive search firm do? They find, approach, and assess candidates for such senior posts in charities as chief executive, director of fundraising, finance director, director of services, and interim managers to be employed for an agreed period. Because the executive search firm you choose will determine what board members will ever see and meet, this is an area where much more thought than usual needs to go into a decision.

Charity boards generally appoint a chief executive once every five or six years, a rate far too slow to give an effective feel for making this type of appointment. The next section summarizes the process of an executive search for the charity sector, what a sector specialist will do that a generalist agency won’t, and the questions that separate the two.

What a charity executive search is, and how it differs from ordinary recruitment

Executive search is, by definition, an active approach. A consultant will explore the market for a role, map out who is doing it now or who is up a level and approach those people directly. Contingency recruitment is a reactive approach: advertise, trawl your own current database, and send you the CVs of anyone who applies. You pay a contingency agency when someone is appointed; you pay a search firm on a staged basis whether or not someone is appointed.

With a charity’s chief executive, a search is normally the most appropriate route since the best candidates are not actively searching for new roles and will therefore not be visiting job boards. A fundraising manager or an executive assistant, on the other hand, can usually be found through a contingency arrangement more cheaply.

Few firms use a search methodology for jobs that would otherwise be advertised on contingency terms. The Maine Group is one of those firms. Its consultants initially meet all clients in the workplace before starting a search, and the firm applies that same technique, dubbed The Maine Method, to each of its five divisions, which includes Maine Charity. The upshot: a mid-range charity job is researched and contacted, not advertised and screened.

Why sector specialism changes who reaches your shortlist

Pay is the obvious example. The latest result from ACEVO’s Pay and Equalities Survey 2025 included responses from 703 of the UK’s charity chief executives. The median was £59,850. Charity Finance’s 2025 survey of the 100 largest charities in the UK showed the median was £192,000-a climb from £175,000 in 2023 and £155,000 in 2019. In both these cases, it is the same job but in a different section of the sector. A recruitment agency which cannot identify where in those two extremes your organisation sits would provide poor advice to candidates, who would then be likely to walk away from your offer.

The same survey also revealed that for charity chief executives, there is a 10.6 per cent pay gap between men and women: men with median salaries of £64,067 versus £57,250 for women. A search firm which captures and compares its own data (for longlist, shortlist and appointment) on diversity will be able to demonstrate to your panel at the outset where candidates are stopping. A firm which does not will deliver the shortlist in black-and-white – as though it fell from the sky.

A firm with sector knowledge will be able to make smaller distinctions. A consultant who has appointed fundraising directors can distinguish one who has helped generate unrestricted income from scratch from one who has managed a major statutory grant. A generalist sees both as £4m of raised funds.

The compliance work that sits behind a charity appointment

From 1 August 2018, the rules about automatic disqualification have been extended to senior charity managers as well as trustees. The most senior manager who reports directly to the board is the chief executive, and the most senior person in the charity who has control of money is the finance director. These are defined by the role they do rather than by their job title. The grounds for disqualification are convictions for dishonesty or deception that are not spent, certain offenses related to terrorism, bribery, and money laundering, contempt of court, and having a notice imposing listing on the sex offenders register.

In practice, though, the charity must ask for the declaration before the appointment, not after; the Charity Commission has model declarations for trustees and senior managers and a disqualified person may make an application to the Commission for a dispensation. Ask another agency which does that step in its procedures. An experienced search agency in the sector will say that it obtains the declaration during the offer stage and checks the Individual Insolvency Register, the Companies House register of disqualified directors and the Commission’s register of removed trustees. A less competent agency will just say that you are legally obliged to do that, which is correct, and do nothing further.

Two additional points should be added to this discussion. If a posting involves working with children or vulnerable adults, the work should be DBS checked at the relevant level, with the organisation aware of this requirement in advance and not simply subjecting a basic check to the posting. In addition, any agency registered to do business in the UK should be following the guidance of the Employment Agencies Act 1973 and the Conduct of Employment Agencies and Employment Businesses Regulations 2003 on fees, candidate data and terms of business. Participation in the Recruitment and Employment Confederation would be a reasonable marker of an agency that understands the need to follow the law, but by itself that is not enough.

Seven questions to ask before you sign

Work your way through each of the agencies you have found using this process and then review the information you have gained:

  • How many posts have you supported as a chief executive or director in the last two years?
  • Can you give me two references for my work?
  • Who runs this search daily, and will she or he come to the briefing, shortlist, and final panel?
  • How do you produce the longlist?
  • If a company says it has built a list for mapping out different agencies, it means that it is doing an active search. In the opposite case, if a company says it has a huge database, it means it is doing a database recall.
  • How do you approach disqualification, references, and the right to work?
  • What information do you gather about diversity?
  • Will it be given to our panel?
  • What are your fees?
  • What if the successful candidate leaves within six months?
  • Who writes the material for applicants?
  • Can I see it?
  • Would I be able to see material that your company has written for a similar vacancy?

Fees, guarantees and what happens when it goes wrong

Retention search billing can be divided into three parts: when the firm is retained, upon delivery of the shortlist and upon the commencement of employment by the candidate. Fees are often set as a percentage of the first year’s salary for the placed candidate (ranging from 20% to 30%), and charity rates are usually lower than commercial rates. Contingency agencies will only be billed when a candidate is placed, at a lower rate. Rate

Get the failure words in text before you appoint anyone, because agencies use the word “guarantee” for three quite totally different things. A gratis substitute in case of failure signifies the agency will look for once more completely free, which means very little when you’ve lost confidence in the firm. A rebate gives a proportion of the cost on a sliding scale, so a month-to-month career change might give you 30% of it back. A refund is simply that: you get your cash back.

The Maine Group offers 100 days at 100% cash protection with no fees in advance, and our fee is payable only after a successful placement. This is more than the usual industry standards and, as such, offers a fair basis on which to compare other agencies’ terms.

Keep the board close to the process.

Board effectiveness and equality, diversity and inclusion are principles in the Charity Governance Code, and a chief executive appointment is a good opportunity to put them into practice. You need to be clear in your mind beforehand about who will be on the panel, who will take the final decision, and what will happen if they disagree – and to discuss it at the briefing meeting. Search consultants regularly point out how interestingly good candidates disappear when it takes two or three weeks to put together an unplanned panel.

Use the briefing meeting to determine the timetable, and put the panel dates into your diary at the same time. It is very reasonable to expect a search for a charity’s chief executive to take from six to 12 weeks from the briefing date to making an offer, taking into account the appointee’s notice period, which is usually three months at that level. If a firm are promising to produce a shortlist significantly faster, they are often doing so because they already have someone in mind.

Signs to walk away

CVs received within 48 hours of the initial contact with no consultant involved in the process having met your team or visited the environment where the work will take place; A consultant failing to disclose the name of the individual carrying out the work; No charity client prepared to accept a reference call; terms of business are not being produced until your panel has met with the candidates; you are being referred from a firm that can only offer you an interim worker on a day rate.

A practical first step

Draft a one-page profile on salary range, reporting relationships, panel members, timing, and the performance expectations for the appointee in the first year. Send this to two or three agencies and, in writing, ask for each agency’s process for the search, their fees, and their failure as well as success criteria. The quality of the written response you receive will say far more than any credentials.

Maine Charity-Working with not-for-profit organisations for over 25 years. To read more about the positions we have successfully recruited for the not-for-profit sector in the United Kingdom, consult our job boards on fundraising and philanthropy, executive assistants, HR, and senior leadership. Call us on 020 7734 7341 or go to the Maine Charity division page.

Frequently asked questions

What does a charity executive search involve?

Charity executive search is a proactive form of recruitment for senior jobs in the charity sector. Instead of advertising a role and waiting to receive applicants, the consultant carries out a market mapping exercise, makes direct approaches, and evaluates candidates against a brief agreed with your board.

How much do charity executive recruitment agencies charge?

Search fees (retained) are usually 20%-30% of the successful candidate’s first year salary and paid in instalments. Rates in the charity sector are usually lower than commercial rates. Contingency agencies only charge if they recruit someone. The Maine Group will not charge up front, and we only take our fee when the candidate has started work.

What is the length of the search for a charity’s chief executive officer?

The usual period between the briefing and offer is six to 12 weeks, plus the leave period of the successful candidate (which at the chief executive level is normally three months).

Do charity recruitment agencies provide trustees’ recruitment as well as that of staff?

Yes, they do. As trustee roles are typically paid differently and involve a different process and different pool of candidates, it is important to specifically ask the firm whether it has done a trustee search, rather than take it for granted it is something it does as part of its executive search activity.

Must the agency be based in London?

On the other hand, the majority of searches are by phone and video, and there is more need for knowledge of the sector than for a location. Being based in London gives an advantage if the role necessitates a number of face-to-face meetings or if candidates in a particular specialist area tend to be based in the capital.

Meeta Sahni

About the Author

Meeta Sahni

Meeta brings 25 years of experience in talent consulting, with a focus on leadership, wellness, and empowering people. She speaks and coaches on mental health in the workplace, women in business, and authentic leadership.

Recruitment

How Long Does It Take to Hire Through a Recruitment Agency?

TL;DR

Most permanent hires in the UK take roughly four to eight weeks from brief to accepted offer. Temporary and interim placements can move in a matter of days.

The three biggest variables are the clarity of your brief, the seniority and scarcity of the role, and how quickly your own team makes decisions.

A good agency shortens the timeline by reaching passive candidates, screening thoroughly, and sending a tight shortlist rather than a stack of CVs.

At The Maine Group, our process, The Maine Method, is designed to take you from brief to offer efficiently, and we back every permanent placement with a 100-day, 100% financial guarantee.

“So, how long is this actually going to take?” It is almost always the first question a hiring manager asks us, and it is a fair one. Every day a seat sits empty has a cost, whether that shows up as missed deadlines, an overstretched team, or opportunities that quietly slip away. After more than 30 years placing people into London businesses across secretarial and business support, HR, charity, sales and marketing, we have learned that the honest answer is never a single number. It depends. What we can do, though, is show you exactly what it depends on, give you realistic ranges to plan around, and walk you through every stage so there are no surprises.

This guide sets out typical UK recruitment timelines, the factors that speed things up or slow them down, and a stage-by-stage look at how we run a search. We have also included a real, anonymised case study from our own desk, because timelines make far more sense when you can see them play out on an actual role.

The short answer: typical UK recruitment timelines

If you want a planning figure to work with today, here is what we tend to see across the roles we handle. These ranges assume a reasonably clear brief and a hiring team that is available to review shortlists and interview without long gaps.

Type of hire Time to shortlist Time to accepted offer
Temporary / interim 24 to 72 hours 2 to 7 days
Junior to mid permanent 5 to 10 working days 3 to 5 weeks
Senior / specialist permanent 1 to 3 weeks 5 to 8 weeks
Executive / hard-to-fill 2 to 4 weeks 6 to 12 weeks

A useful rule of thumb: shortlisting is the part a specialist agency can compress most, because we are already talking to the right people. The offer stage is where timelines often stretch, and that part is usually within your control rather than ours. More on that shortly.

What actually affects how long hiring takes

Two identical-looking vacancies can take wildly different amounts of time to fill. When a search runs long, the reason almost always sits in one of the following areas.

1. The clarity of your brief

This is the single biggest lever, and the one most people underestimate. A vague brief (“we need a strong all-rounder”) forces us to guess, which means more back and forth and a slower shortlist. A sharp brief that separates the genuine must-haves from the nice-to-haves lets us move quickly and confidently. Taking an extra half hour at the start to get this right routinely saves a week or more later.

2. Role seniority and how scarce the skills are

Broadly, the more senior or specialised the role, the smaller the pool and the longer the search. An experienced Executive Assistant in central London can often be shortlisted within days. A niche fundraising lead with a specific sector background may take a few weeks of proactive headhunting to surface, because the best people are usually employed and not scrolling job boards.

3. Your internal decision-making speed

Here is the uncomfortable truth we share with every client: the market moves faster than most hiring processes. Strong candidates typically hold more than one option. If it takes ten days to arrange a first interview and another two weeks to reach a decision, you will lose people, and the timeline resets. Agencies cannot fix internal delays, but flagging them early is part of the job.

4. Market conditions

Candidate availability shifts with the economy, the season, and even notice periods. In a candidate-short market you compete harder and move faster. It is worth keeping an eye on independent labour market data, such as the ONS labour market overview and the REC JobsOutlook, to understand the conditions you are hiring into.

Here is how those factors tend to pull in each direction.

Speeds the process up Slows the process down
A clear, prioritised brief A vague or shifting brief
Fast interview scheduling Long gaps between stages
A single, empowered decision-maker Multiple sign-offs and diaries
Realistic, market-aligned salary A package below the going rate
Working with one specialist agency Briefing five agencies at once

From brief to offer: every stage of The Maine Method explained

Over three decades we have refined a process we call The Maine Method. It is deliberately built to be an executive-search-style service, even for contingency roles, because doing the groundwork properly is what makes the shortlist small and the placement stick. Here is what actually happens, and roughly how long each part takes.

Stage What happens Typical duration
1. Discovery We meet you, your team and, wherever possible, your workplace to understand the role, culture and must-haves. Day 1 to 2
2. Search & sourcing We tap our network, database and passive market, headhunting people who are not actively applying. Day 2 to 10
3. Screening & profiling We interview and reference candidates and run personality profiling as standard to check fit, not just skills. Runs alongside sourcing
4. Shortlist of three We present a tightly matched shortlist, usually three candidates, with honest commentary on each. By day 7 to 14
5. Interview & selection We coordinate interviews, gather feedback both ways and keep momentum up. 1 to 3 weeks
6. Offer & onboarding We manage the offer, help with contracts, and support the first day and beyond. 3 to 7 days

A few things are worth drawing out. In stage two, the real value is reaching people who are not on the job boards at all. The strongest candidate for your role is very often someone who was not looking until the right opportunity was put in front of them properly. In stage four, we deliberately keep the shortlist small. The aim is that the hardest part of your day is choosing between three genuinely excellent people, rather than wading through forty CVs that half-fit. And in stage six, we do not disappear at the offer. We help with onboarding because a fast hire that leaves in month two is not really a fast hire at all.

Case study: an HR Manager filled in 18 working days

To show how the timeline plays out in practice, here is a recent search from our HR desk. Details have been anonymised at the client’s request, but the sequence and dates are real.

The situation

A mid-sized membership organisation in central London had been trying to fill a standalone HR Manager role for nearly three months through job adverts and two other agencies. They had seen plenty of CVs but no one who combined the operational HR experience with the softer, people-first style their culture needed. The role had become urgent, as their outgoing HR lead was working a notice period that was about to end.

What we did

  • Ran a proper discovery session on day one, visiting the office to get a feel for the team and pinning down the three qualities that genuinely mattered versus the ones on the wish list.
  • Focused the search on passive candidates who were settled but potentially open, rather than re-advertising to the same active pool the client had already exhausted.
  • Used personality profiling to sense-check cultural fit before anyone reached interview, which is standard on our permanent roles.
  • Presented a shortlist of three on day eight, each with candid notes on strengths and any watch-outs.

The result

The client interviewed all three within a week, held second-stage conversations with two, and made an offer on day 16. The successful candidate accepted on day 18. She started once her notice concluded and, in the client’s words a few months on, had been “adding value from day one.” The role that had resisted filling for three months closed in under four working weeks once the search was run properly and the client kept the interview process tight. It is a neat illustration of the point above: the sourcing was ours to accelerate, and the client’s quick, decisive interviewing did the rest.

How to speed up your hiring without cutting corners

Rushing a hire and speeding one up are not the same thing. You can genuinely shorten the timeline while raising quality if you focus on the parts that are within your gift.

  • Write down your three non-negotiables before you brief anyone. If everything is essential, nothing is, and the search slows.
  • Block interview slots in advance. Reserving two windows in your diary at the outset removes the single most common cause of delay.
  • Name your decision-maker early. Searches drift when it is unclear who has the final say.
  • Benchmark the salary against the current market, not last year’s. A strong package attracts a faster yes.
  • Back one specialist rather than briefing several agencies. Counter-intuitively, exclusivity usually produces a better shortlist sooner, because the recruiter can justify investing real headhunting time in your role.

Why speed is only half the story

It is tempting to judge a recruitment process purely on how fast it fills the seat. We would gently push back on that. A hire that lands quickly but leaves within a few months costs far more than the fortnight you saved, once you factor in the rehiring, the lost momentum and the impact on the team. This is exactly why we build fit-checking into the process and why we underwrite our permanent placements with a 100-day, 100% financial guarantee. If a placement does not work out within that window, we put it right. Sharing that risk keeps everyone honest about getting the match right the first time, not just the fast time.

Frequently asked questions

How long does it take to hire through a recruitment agency in the UK?

For permanent roles, expect roughly four to eight weeks from brief to accepted offer, depending on seniority and how quickly you interview. Temporary and interim placements can be filled within days, sometimes within 24 hours for well-defined roles.

Why is using an agency faster than hiring directly?

A specialist agency is already in conversation with relevant candidates, including passive ones who are not applying anywhere. That removes the slowest part of direct hiring, which is building a qualified pool from scratch, and replaces a flood of applications with a short, pre-screened shortlist.

What slows down the recruitment process the most?

In our experience it is rarely the candidate market. The most common delays are an unclear brief, slow interview scheduling, and too many sign-offs. All three are within the hiring organisation’s control, which is good news, because it means you can influence the timeline directly.

How many candidates should a recruiter put forward?

Quality matters far more than quantity. We typically present a shortlist of three closely matched candidates rather than a long list, so your time goes into meeting genuinely suitable people rather than filtering CVs.

What happens if the person I hire does not work out?

Reputable agencies offer a rebate or replacement guarantee. At The Maine Group, permanent placements are covered by a 100-day, 100% financial guarantee, so the risk is shared rather than resting entirely on you.

Can you recruit quickly for urgent or temporary roles?

Yes. Temporary and interim cover is where speed is greatest. Because we maintain an active pool of available professionals, we can often introduce suitable candidates within a day or two of your brief.

Ready to start the clock?

If you have a role to fill and want a realistic timeline for it specifically, rather than a general range, we are happy to talk it through. Share the brief with us and we will tell you honestly how quickly we think we can move, and what would help it move faster. Get in touch with The Maine Group and let us take it from brief to offer.

Meeta Sahni

About the Author

Meeta Sahni

Meeta brings 25 years of experience in talent consulting, with a focus on leadership, wellness, and empowering people. She speaks and coaches on mental health in the workplace, women in business, and authentic leadership.

Recruitment

Local, National or Global? Where We Source Your Next Hire

TL;DR

The right candidate is not always where you expect. Sometimes they are a few streets away in the City, sometimes a timezone away in Dubai.

As a London recruitment agency with more than 30 years on our doorstep and 20 years of international placements, we search at three levels: local, national and global.

Local suits roles that need daily office presence and London market knowledge. National widens the pool for hybrid and remote roles. Global is for niche skills, overseas offices and international expansion.

Our advice is simple: match the search radius to the role, not to habit. We help you choose, then source accordingly, across London, the wider UK, Dubai, Europe, Africa and the US.

“Where is the right person for this role, actually?” It is a deceptively big question. For years the default answer for a London business was “somewhere in London,” and for many roles that is still exactly right. But the working world has stretched. Hybrid patterns have widened what counts as commutable, remote roles have opened up the whole of the UK, and a growing number of our clients are hiring for offices in the Gulf, mainland Europe, Africa and the United States. The search radius has become a genuine strategic decision.

We have spent more than three decades placing people into London businesses, and around twenty years running international searches alongside that. So we tend to look at every brief through the same lens: what is the smallest search area that will reliably give you an excellent shortlist? Sometimes that is a postcode. Sometimes it is a continent. This guide walks through how we think about local, national and global sourcing, where our reach extends, and how to pick the right approach for your next hire.

Start local: why our London roots still matter

There is a reason we have stayed based in the heart of our client base in London’s West End and City. Proximity is an advantage you can feel. When a role needs someone in the office most days, a strong understanding of London salaries, sectors and commuting realities matters enormously. A candidate who looks perfect on paper but faces a 90-minute each-way commute rarely lasts, however good the match.

Local sourcing is usually the right call for office-based support and business-critical roles where presence and pace count: Executive Assistants, Office Managers, front-of-house and team-support positions. It is also where our network runs deepest, because relationships built over 30 years in the same square mile mean we often already know the person you need.

Going national: sourcing across the wider UK

The rise of hybrid and remote working has quietly rewritten the map. For roles that only need a presence a couple of days a week, or none at all, restricting your search to Greater London can mean overlooking excellent people an hour or two up the line. Widening to a national search opens up a far larger pool, which is particularly valuable for specialist or hard-to-fill positions where the London-only market is thin.

National sourcing tends to suit HR specialists, marketing and digital roles, finance functions and consultancy positions where the work travels well and the talent does not need to sit at a specific desk. The trade-off to weigh is culture and connection: remote hires can thrive, but they need a deliberate onboarding plan rather than being left to find their feet. That is exactly the sort of thing we help clients think through before the search begins.

Thinking global: talent across Dubai, Europe, Africa and the US

For around twenty years we have delivered international recruitment alongside our UK work, and it has grown into a core part of what we do. Global search comes into its own in three situations: when the skills you need are genuinely scarce in the UK, when you are staffing an overseas office, and when you are expanding into a new market and need people who already understand it on the ground.

Dubai and the Gulf

The Gulf is one of our most active international regions. UK organisations opening a Dubai presence often need senior support and management hires who combine international professionalism with genuine local market knowledge. We source into the region regularly and understand the practical realities, from cultural fit to the pace of setting up a new office abroad.

Europe, Africa and the United States

Beyond the Gulf, our reach extends across mainland Europe, Africa and the US. Each market has its own rhythms around notice periods, expectations and the way senior candidates prefer to be approached. Rather than treat international hiring as “UK recruitment, but further away,” we adapt the search to the region, which is what makes the difference between a shortlist that looks impressive and one that actually lands.

Here is a simple view of where we search and what each level is best suited to.

Search level Best for Typical roles
Local (London) Office-based roles needing daily presence and London market knowledge EAs, Office Managers, team support, front of house
National (UK) Hybrid and remote roles, and thin specialist markets HR, marketing, finance, consultancy
Global Scarce skills, overseas offices, market expansion Regional leadership, senior support, specialist hires

How we decide where to search for your role

We do not start with a map. We start with the role, and the search radius follows from it. In practice, four questions usually settle it.

  • How much physical presence does the role genuinely require? Daily presence points local, occasional presence opens up national, none opens up global.
  • How scarce is the skill set? The rarer the skills, the wider we cast, because the best fit for a niche role is rarely on your doorstep.
  • Where does the role actually sit? A role anchored to a Dubai office is a Gulf search, not a London one, however British the parent company.
  • What is the wider hiring strategy? If you plan to grow in a region, hiring people already rooted there pays off well beyond the first placement.

The honest bit we share with clients: casting wider is not automatically better. A global search for a role that only needs someone in the office on Tuesdays simply adds cost and complication. Matching the radius to the reality is the whole game.

What changes when you hire internationally

International hiring is rewarding, but it is not the same process on a longer runway. A few things shift, and planning for them up front keeps the search smooth.

Consideration What to plan for
Compliance and right to work Local employment rules, visas and sponsorship vary by market and need factoring into the timeline
Timezones and interviews Scheduling across regions takes coordination; we manage this so momentum is not lost
Salary and package norms Benchmarks, benefits and expectations differ by country and should be set to the local market
Notice periods These vary widely internationally and affect realistic start dates
Cultural fit on the ground Local market knowledge often matters as much as the CV for roles based abroad

None of this should put you off. It simply means an international search rewards an experienced partner who has run them before, rather than a scramble across job boards you cannot read.

Case study: staffing a new Dubai office from London

Details below have been anonymised at the client’s request, but the shape of the search is real.

The situation

A London-headquartered professional services firm was opening its first office in Dubai and needed a senior Office Manager to anchor it: someone who could set up operations from scratch, represent the firm confidently with regional partners, and bridge the London and Gulf ways of working. Their instinct had been to hire in London and relocate, but early conversations suggested the strongest candidates would be people already established in the region.

What we did

  • Reframed the search as a Gulf search rather than a London one, drawing on our international desk and regional network.
  • Prioritised candidates who combined international professional standards with genuine on-the-ground knowledge of Dubai.
  • Ran personality profiling as standard to check the candidate could operate autonomously in a brand-new office far from head office.
  • Coordinated interviews across timezones so the London leadership and the successful candidate could meet without weeks of diary friction.

The result

We presented a focused shortlist, and the firm appointed an Office Manager already based in the region who was able to start quickly and had the new office operational within weeks. Because the hire understood the local market from day one, the leadership team could stay focused on the launch rather than on hand-holding. It is a clear example of the core point: the right person was never in London at all, and searching there first would only have slowed things down.

Making the right choice for your business

If you are weighing up where to search for an upcoming role, a few practical steps make the decision easier.

  • Define the presence the role truly needs before you set the location, not after.
  • Be honest about how scarce the skills are; if the UK pool is genuinely thin, widening early saves weeks.
  • Where a role is tied to an overseas office, plan for local sourcing and the compliance that comes with it from the outset.
  • Lean on a partner who works across all three levels, so you are not forced to fit the role to whichever pool a specialist happens to cover.

Frequently asked questions

Do you only recruit in London?

No. London is our home and our deepest network, but we source nationally across the UK and internationally too. We work across Dubai and the wider Gulf, mainland Europe, Africa and the United States, choosing the right search level for each role.

What makes a good global recruitment agency in London?

The ability to search at every level rather than defaulting to one. A strong local network for office-based roles, national reach for hybrid and remote positions, and genuine international experience for overseas offices and scarce skills, all under one relationship.

Is international recruitment slower than hiring in the UK?

It can involve extra steps, such as right-to-work checks, cross-timezone interviews and local salary benchmarking. With an experienced partner managing those in parallel, an international search does not have to feel slow, and it often reaches better-suited candidates.

When should I search nationally rather than just in London?

Whenever a role does not need daily office presence, or when the London-only market for a specialist skill is too thin. Hybrid and remote roles in particular benefit from opening the search to the whole UK.

Can you help us staff an office abroad?

Yes. Staffing overseas offices, particularly in Dubai and the Gulf, is a core part of our international work. We prioritise candidates who combine professional standards with real local market knowledge so the office is productive quickly.

How do you decide where to source candidates for a role?

We start from the role, not the map. The required presence, how scarce the skills are, where the role physically sits and your wider growth plans together tell us whether to search locally, nationally or globally.

Not sure how far to look? Let us help you decide

Whether your next hire is a few streets away or a few timezones away, the starting point is the same: a proper conversation about the role. Tell us what you are trying to achieve and we will advise honestly on where the right person is most likely to be, then run the search to find them. Explore our global recruitment reach or get in touch with The Maine Group to talk it through.

Meeta Sahni

About the Author

Meeta Sahni

Meeta brings 25 years of experience in talent consulting, with a focus on leadership, wellness, and empowering people. She speaks and coaches on mental health in the workplace, women in business, and authentic leadership.

Recruitment

How Recruiters Find and Shortlist the Right People (Including the Ones Who Aren’t Looking)

TL;DR

The best person for your role is usually not applying for jobs. They are settled, doing good work, and open to the right approach rather than actively looking.

Recruiters find candidates through three routes: an established network, proactive headhunting of the passive market, and referrals built on reputation.

Finding people is only half the job. Shortlisting is where a good recruiter earns their keep, screening for skills, then checking culture and personality fit.

At The Maine Group we run personality profiling as standard and present a tight shortlist, usually three genuinely matched people, so your time goes into meeting the right candidates rather than sifting CVs.

Here is a truth the recruitment industry does not say out loud often enough: if you only ever meet the people who apply, you are only ever meeting part of the market. Job adverts reach the roughly one in five professionals who happen to be actively looking on the day you post. Everyone else, the settled, the busy, the quietly-open-but-not-searching, never sees it. And more often than not, the perfect person for your role is sitting comfortably in that second group.

So how do recruiters actually find the right people, including the ones who are not looking, and then narrow a wide field down to a shortlist you can trust? After more than 30 years doing exactly this from our base in London, we can pull back the curtain. This is how good sourcing and shortlisting really work, and where the craft lives.

Why the best candidate is usually not applying

At any given moment, the working population splits into two groups. Active candidates are on the job boards, updating their CVs and applying. Passive candidates are employed, engaged, and not looking, but would consider a genuinely better opportunity if it landed on their desk. The passive group is far larger, and it tends to contain the people who are good enough that they rarely need to job hunt.

This is the single biggest reason to use a specialist recruiter rather than relying on adverts alone. Reaching passive candidates takes a network, credibility and the confidence to make a direct, well-judged approach. Here is how the two groups compare.

Active candidates Passive candidates
How you reach them Job adverts, applications Direct approach, referrals, network
Share of the market The minority who are looking today The larger, settled majority
Typical quality signal Available now, motivated to move Often high performers, currently valued
What it takes to engage them A good advert A credible recruiter and the right pitch

How recruiters actually find candidates

Good sourcing is rarely one channel. It is several, used together and weighted to the role. These are the routes that do the heavy lifting.

An established network and database

Three decades in the same market means we already know a great many of the people our clients need, and have relationships with many more. A well-tended network is not a dusty list of old CVs; it is live relationships with professionals whose careers we have followed, sometimes for years. When a brief lands that fits someone we know, the search can start with a phone call rather than a blank page.

Proactive headhunting of the passive market

For roles where the right person is unlikely to be applying, we go and find them. This is the part people picture when they think of executive search: identifying the individuals doing the exact work you need elsewhere, and approaching them thoughtfully. We run this executive-search-style approach even for contingency roles, because it is what surfaces candidates who would never respond to an advert.

Referrals and reputation

Great candidates know other great candidates. A reputation built on treating people well, both clients and candidates, means professionals are willing to recommend peers and to take our call when we ring. Referrals often produce some of the strongest introductions precisely because they come with a built-in endorsement.

The mix shifts by role. Here is roughly how we weight the channels.

Sourcing channel Best suited to Reaches
Network and database Roles similar to ones we place often Known, trusted professionals
Proactive headhunting Niche, senior or hard-to-fill roles The passive market
Referrals Any role, especially specialist ones Peer-recommended candidates
Targeted advertising High-volume or entry-level roles The active market

From long list to shortlist: how we screen and match

Finding people is the visible half of recruitment. Shortlisting is the half that actually protects your time and your hire. A long list of maybes helps no one. The skill is in narrowing it down responsibly, and that happens in layers.

Screening for skills and experience

First, the objective layer. Does the person have the experience, competencies and track record the role genuinely needs? We interview candidates properly and take up references, so that by the time anyone reaches your shortlist, the basics are already verified rather than assumed.

Personality profiling as standard

This is where we go further than many. On our permanent placements we run personality profiling as standard, not as a paid extra. Skills tell you whether someone can do the job; profiling helps reveal how they work, how they communicate and whether they will thrive in your particular environment. It is one of the most reliable ways to reduce the risk of a hire who looks right on paper but does not settle.

Matching to your culture, not just your job spec

A job spec describes a role. It does not describe your team, your pace or your way of doing things. That is why we insist on getting to know you, your people and, wherever possible, your workplace before we shortlist. Cultural and performance alignment is what turns a competent hire into a long-term one, and it is impossible to judge from a CV alone.

Why we present a shortlist of three

You might expect a recruiter to prove their worth by sending you a stack of candidates. We take the opposite view. Our aim is that the hardest decision you face is choosing between three genuinely excellent, closely matched people, rather than wading through forty CVs that half-fit. A shortlist of three respects your time and signals that the screening has already been done rigorously. If the first three are not right, that tells us something useful about the brief, and we recalibrate rather than pad the list.

Case study: finding a fundraiser who was not looking

Details have been anonymised at the client’s request, but the search itself is real.

The situation

A national charity needed a Senior Philanthropy Manager to lead its major-donor programme. The role demanded a rare mix: the technical fundraising expertise to secure significant gifts, and the warmth to build long-term relationships with high-value supporters. The charity had advertised twice and met several capable applicants, but none combined both sides well enough. The best people, it turned out, were all happily employed elsewhere.

What we did

  • Started from our charity network rather than a fresh advert, drawing on relationships built across the sector over many years.
  • Identified and approached a small group of passive candidates who were excelling in similar roles and not actively looking.
  • Ran personality profiling on the strongest prospects to check the relationship-building style the role really needed.
  • Presented a shortlist of three, each with candid notes on strengths and any areas to explore at interview.

The result

The successful candidate had not applied for a single role in over four years and would never have seen the advert. She was open, however, to the right conversation, which is exactly what our approach is built to start. She was appointed, settled quickly, and the profiling proved accurate: her donor-relationship style was a natural fit for the charity’s culture. It is the clearest possible illustration of the point that opened this article. The best person was not in the applicant pile at all.

What this means for you as a hiring manager

If you are recruiting soon, a few things follow naturally from all of the above.

  • Do not judge the market by your applicants alone. The strongest candidates are usually the ones you will never see unless someone goes and finds them.
  • Value a short, well-screened shortlist over a long one. Quantity is easy; a shortlist you can trust is the hard, valuable part.
  • Share the real culture of your team, not just the job description. The more we understand your environment, the more accurately we can match for fit.
  • Ask how a recruiter checks fit beyond the CV. Profiling and proper screening are what stand between you and an expensive mismatch.

Frequently asked questions

How do recruitment agencies find candidates?

Through a combination of an established network and database, proactive headhunting of people who are not actively looking, and referrals built on reputation. Targeted advertising has a place for high-volume roles, but for most quality hires the network and headhunting do the heavy lifting.

What is a passive candidate?

A passive candidate is someone who is employed and not job hunting, but would consider the right opportunity if approached well. This group is larger than the active job-seeking market and often contains high performers who rarely need to look for work.

How does the shortlisting process work?

After sourcing a wider field, a recruiter screens candidates for skills and experience, interviews and references them, and then assesses culture and personality fit. The result should be a small, closely matched shortlist rather than a long list of maybes.

Why do you only present a few candidates?

Because a tightly matched shortlist respects your time and reflects thorough screening. We aim to present around three genuinely suitable people so your effort goes into meeting the right candidates, not filtering CVs. If those three are not right, we recalibrate the brief.

Do you use personality profiling?

Yes. On permanent placements we run personality profiling as standard rather than as an add-on. It helps reveal how someone works and communicates, which reduces the risk of a hire who looks right on paper but does not settle into the team.

Can you find candidates who are not applying for jobs?

Yes, and it is one of the main reasons to use a specialist recruiter. Through headhunting and our network we reach settled professionals who would never respond to an advert but are open to the right conversation.

Looking for someone who isn’t looking for you?

If your last advert did not surface the right person, the right person may simply not have been looking. That is exactly the search we are built for. Tell us about the role and the team behind it, and we will go and find the people who fit, including the ones you would never reach on your own. Get in touch with The Maine Group to start the conversation.

Meeta Sahni

About the Author

Meeta Sahni

Meeta brings 25 years of experience in talent consulting, with a focus on leadership, wellness, and empowering people. She speaks and coaches on mental health in the workplace, women in business, and authentic leadership.

Recruitment

How to Create an LGBTQIA+ Friendly Recruitment Process

At The Maine Group, we believe that fostering an inclusive workplace starts with the recruitment process. As we celebrate Pride Month, it’s essential to highlight the importance of LGBTQIA+ friendly recruitment practices.

Here’s how you can ensure your hiring process is inclusive and welcoming:

1. Use Inclusive Language

Ensure that your job descriptions and application forms use gender-neutral language. Avoid phrases that might inadvertently exclude non-binary or transgender individuals. Instead of using “he/she,” opt for “they” or simply address the candidate directly.

2. Promote Your Commitment

Clearly state your commitment to diversity and inclusion in your job postings and on your company website. Highlight any existing policies that support LGBTQIA+ employees, such as non-discrimination policies, diversity training, and employee resource groups. This transparency reassures potential candidates that your company values inclusivity.

3. Train Your Hiring Team

Provide training for all employees involved in the hiring process to raise awareness about unconscious biases and the importance of LGBTQIA+ inclusion. This will help ensure that all candidates are treated fairly and respectfully, creating a more welcoming environment from the very first interaction.

4. Create a Safe Interview Environment

During interviews, avoid making assumptions about a candidate’s personal life or identity. Use the name and pronouns the candidate prefers and encourage open and respectful dialogue. This approach helps candidates feel valued and respected, which can positively influence their perception of your company.

5. Offer Benefits that Support LGBTQIA+ Employees

Make sure your benefits package includes comprehensive health coverage for LGBTQIA+ employees, such as transgender-inclusive healthcare and mental health support. Additionally, offer policies that support diverse family structures. These benefits demonstrate a genuine commitment to the well-being of all employees.

6. Showcase Your Diversity

Highlight the diversity within your current team and share stories of LGBTQIA+ employees on your website and social media. This demonstrates that your company values and supports diversity, making it more attractive to potential candidates who prioritize an inclusive work environment.

7. Seek Feedback and Improve

Regularly seek feedback from LGBTQIA+ employees about their experiences with your recruitment process and workplace environment. Use this feedback to make continuous improvements and show your commitment to creating an inclusive workplace. This ongoing dialogue ensures that your practices evolve to meet the needs of your employees.

By integrating these practices, you can create a recruitment process that not only attracts top talent but also fosters a diverse and inclusive workplace where everyone can thrive. Celebrating Pride Month is more than a gesture; it’s a commitment to ongoing support and inclusivity.

Happy Pride Month from all of us at The Maine Group!

At The Maine Group, we are dedicated to helping businesses build inclusive and supportive work environments. If you need assistance in developing LGBTQIA+ friendly recruitment practices, contact us today to learn how we can support your diversity and inclusion efforts.

Meeta Sahni

About the Author

Meeta Sahni

Meeta brings 25 years of experience in talent consulting, with a focus on leadership, wellness, and empowering people. She speaks and coaches on mental health in the workplace, women in business, and authentic leadership.