How to Find a Personal Assistant Through Agencies in London: A Decision-Making Framework
On average, a direct-hire personal assistant will cost your London business an extra 47 hours of time that you will spend looking for, interviewing and screening candidates instead of serving your customers and generating sales. Fortunately, with the aid of a reputable PA recruitment agency, London business leaders can avoid this expense, but it requires the right approach.
This guide is for: Business Owners, CEO & HR Managers in London looking to hire your first PA or replace an existing one through a recruitment agency. You have a real need for dedicated admin support and a sensible budget (£28,000 – £55,000) for a permanent PA.
Who this guide is NOT for: Those seeking virtual assistants on hourly contracts, entrepreneurs needing occasional task support, or businesses outside the Greater London area.
The Direct Answer: How Agency-Based PA Hiring Works
A PA recruitment agency London businesses work with serves as an intermediary between employers and qualified candidates. The agency handles candidate sourcing, initial screening, skills testing, and reference verification, presenting you with a shortlist of vetted professionals who match your specific requirements.
Key definition: A specialist PA recruitment agency focuses exclusively or primarily on administrative, secretarial, and executive support roles, distinguishing them from generalist recruiters who handle all position types. Specialist agencies typically maintain deeper candidate networks and better understand the nuanced skills that separate exceptional PAs from adequate ones.
The typical timeline from initial briefing to candidate placement ranges from one to four weeks for permanent positions, with temporary PA placements often possible within 24–48 hours through established agencies.
The MATCH Framework: Evaluating PA Recruitment Agencies
Having looked at dozens of PA placements in London-based companies, there’s a pattern to what makes a good relationship with an agency and the disappointment of a bad one. The MATCH methodology makes it easy to evaluate.
M – Market Specialisation
Is the agency expert in PA, Executive Assistant and administration recruitment, or do they just do a small amount of PA and admin support recruitment out of the wider placements that they undertake? Office support specialists have more established candidate pipelines and a clearer understanding of the skill sets needed for each role.
Questions to ask: “How much of your overall recruitment spend is PA and administrative support recruitment?” This should be one of the niche service lines that the agency does.
A – Assessment Process
How does the agency screen candidates? Reputable agencies will carry out interviews, skills testing and even personality profiling rather than just send you CVs Make sure the agency has a rigorous screening process.
Warning: “Twenty CVs by the morning?” If this is what they’re offering, then they’re really just a CV shop and not a recruitment partner. Time will tell if the quality matches the quantity!
T – Track Record and Guarantees
Airline Recruitment Agencies Reassure You with Valid Guarantees. Reputable agencies in the industry usually have a three-month replacement guarantee for permanent positions. Some agencies also have even longer periods for guaranteeing placements than that.
Industry scoop: Agencies that have a 100% refund guarantee in place (not just a replacement guarantee) are actually truly sure of the quality of their own candidates.
C – Consultation Depth
A good agent will spend time learning about your business before they interview any PAs. As well as your industry and company, they will want to learn about your people, team dynamics and your management style to help find the right people.
What to expect: A solid telephone briefing takes between 30 minutes and 45 minutes over the phone. The interview will ask questions about how you work, communicate and what you want to achieve in this role (not just what the job description says).
H – Hidden Candidate Access
The candidates that offer the most valuable talent are frequently not searching on the employment sites Established PA recruitment agencies London have long-standing relationships with quality professional people who are actively looking for new positions however are not advertising to do so.
Practical fact: 20+ year established agencies have, over time, built up a network that includes previously placed people who are in the market for their 2nd, third, etc. role. This provides one of the most significant benefits for recruiting through an agency versus going direct.
Step-by-Step: Working With a PA Recruitment Agency
Step 1: Define Your Requirements Before Contact
Before engaging any agency, clarify these essential elements:
- Core responsibilities: What will occupy 80% of your PA’s time?
- Working arrangement: Office-based, hybrid, or remote? Full-time or part-time?
- Experience level: Junior PA (2–3 years), experienced PA (5+ years), or senior EA level?
- Budget range: Include salary, benefits, and recruitment fees in your calculation
- Timeline: When do you need the role filled?
Step 2: Select and Brief Your Agency
Use only 2 or 3 specialist agencies, rather than as many as possible. Professional agencies will want to arrange a briefing call with you to get a good feel for the role. During that call, tell them more than just what is in the job description-describe your company culture, your team, and what you’ve enjoyed / not enjoyed about prior admin help.
Mistake to avoid: Using too many agencies (think 5 or more!) means losing quality, time and effort in each company, as they know they are up against other agencies.
Step 3: Review the Shortlist Strategically
Qualities of a good PA recruitment agency (recommended by the best PA recruitment agency London) should send you only three to five screened candidates rather than scores of unsuitable applicants. Each of these should include:
- A fully qualified CV with checked work history
- A view from the Consultant as to whether they will fit into the company, as well as any reservations
- Details of the candidate’s aspirations and targets.
Step 4: Interview With Purpose
Your agency should brief candidates thoroughly before interviews, but verification remains essential. Focus interview questions on:
- Situational scenarios specific to your business challenges
- Problem-solving approaches for common PA dilemmas
- Communication style compatibility with your working preferences
- Long-term career alignment with the role’s trajectory
Step 5: Decide and help onboard
Once you’ve chosen the right candidate, your agency will help you with offer negotiation, reference checking, start date planning and more. Some agencies even help with onboarding as well, to make sure the placement has a successful first day.
Understanding Agency Fees and Costs
London PA recruitment agency fees are normally either:
Permanent placement fee: The cost of a PA recruitment agency placement is usually between 15% and 25% of the first year’s salary. For example, a PA earning £35,000 a year will cost between £5,250 and £8,750. Most agencies work on a “no placement, no fee” basis, so they will only charge when a candidate is appointed.
Like temp agencies, PA fees are paid directly to the temp and billed to you at a markup on their hourly rate. Margins are typically 15-30% above the worker’s hourly cost. The cost view: Agency fees are a significant investment, so consider the alternative: your hourly rate x 40-60 hours of recruiting effort + risk of a bad hire (roughly 1.5-2x annual salary with recruitment, training, and productivity costs).
Five Mistakes That Derail PA Agency Partnerships
- Giving no detail in job briefs. “Looking for a professional and highly organised PA” – come on! Clearly outline the tasks and challenges of the role, and the environment they’ll be working in.
- Focusing on the lowest costs. The agency fee you get when recruiting the cheapest service indicates the quality of service you’ll receive, the strength of the candidate pipeline and the level of candidate screening.
- Not actioning speedy interview processes. The best PAs get snapped up quickly, so you could be two weeks behind other employers at the interview stage, missing out on your preferred candidates.
- Focusing on candidate skills, not personality. Skills can be learned and trained. Personality can’t. Give equal importance to experience and personal compatibility.
- Avoiding the probation period. Even if you’ve used an agency to pre-screen potential hires, ensure 30-60-90 day goals and review points are agreed early on.
When a Recruitment Agency May Not Be the Right Choice
Important to know: we may not be the best fit; here are some reasons to consider other options: If your budget doesn’t stretch to bringing a great new team member on board with both a competitive salary and agency fee. If you require fewer than 15 hours of PA support per week (think about a virtual assistant); if the role is very niche and its industry knowledge is not easily gauged if you have dedicated HR expertise and proven recruiting systems.
Expert Summary: Key Takeaways
How to source a Personal Assistant – through a PA recruitment agency London companies trust not necessarily have to be difficult, but choosing the right agency is key. When looking for a PA recruitment agency London has to choose from, consider the MATCH criteria – Market specialisation, Assessment, Track record, Consultation and Hidden talent.
The bottom line: Working with a specialist recruitment agency takes much of the risk out of PA recruitment, demystifying a lengthy and often frustrating process. For that investment of around 15-25% of first-year salary, you get a vetted shortlist of candidates with confidence in quality and replacement guarantees.
To do today: Prepare a list of requirements for your PA along the lines of the script in Step 1 above – shortlists will be better when we work with clear requirements, and successful long-term placements follow shortlists.
Ready to Find Your Next Personal Assistant?
The Maine Group have been providing specialist PA, Executive Assistant & administrative recruitment in London since 1987. Our dedicated team understand what sets the best from the rest, because we’ve been helping top employers find the right assistants for over 3 decades, placing candidates in roles that make a difference.
As recruitment specialists, we focus on relationships, not transactions. We spend time working closely with you to understand your company and culture and what we need to deliver. We then carefully select a highly tailored shortlist of relevant and carefully screened candidates.
Our permanent placements come with our 100% market-leading refund guarantee!
Contact The Maine Group today for your PA requirements. Whether for temporary cover, a contract role or a permanent position, our specialist consultants can help you get the best assistant for your business.
Frequently Asked Questions
How quickly can I recruit a PA from a London agency?
Permanent roles – shortlisting of CVs within 1 week of a dedicated brief to a specialist agency and candidates selected for interview within 2-4 weeks of being briefed. Temporary roles – back-to-back assignments in 24-48 hours through the right recruitment agency.
What is the typical cost of using a PA recruitment agency in London?
Generally, placement fees will be somewhere between 15-25% of the candidate’s first year’s salary. For a PA who makes £35,000 a year, the fees will range from £5250 to £8,750. Most agencies work on a contingency basis, meaning you will not pay until a candidate accepts the position and begins working.
Features to look for in a recruitment agency for p.a.
Choose agencies that specialise in PA / administrative placements, that take care of your candidates, offer comprehensive registration procedures, ensure good onward placements and, if possible, guarantee placements, e.g. a 100% refund rather than a hot spare replacement. Ensure that they have an in-depth consultative methodology and a database of viable candidates, including those not actively looking.
What is the difference between a PA and an Executive Assistant?
Both positions require general admin and administrative support such as diary management, travel arrangements, and correspondence management. Executive Assistant: Executive Assistants generally offer more senior business support to C-Suite executives or High Net Worth Individuals and manage strategic projects, sensitive information, and high-level tasks – beyond the traditional PA role.
